Turlier Virginie, Rouquier Amandine, Black David, Josse Gwendal, Auvergnat Arielle, Briant Alain, Dahan Serge, Gassia Véronique, Saint-Martory Christine, Zakaria Wassim, Queille-Roussel Catherine, Grognard-Gourdon Catherine, Thioly-Bensoussan Daphné, Degouy Arnaud, Schmitt Anne-Marie
Centre de Recherche sur la Peau Pierre Fabre, Hôtel Dieu, Toulouse, France.
J Cosmet Laser Ther. 2010 Aug;12(4):195-202. doi: 10.3109/14764172.2010.502461.
The efficacy of numerous hyaluronic acid (HA)-based fillers has been demonstrated by semi-quantitative and qualitative methods, useful in clinical practice, but poorly reliable.
To objectively evaluate the efficacy of a HA gel in treating nasolabial folds (NLFs) over a 9-12-month follow-up period.
A total of 47 adult patients with moderate to severe NLFs received one or two injections of HA gel. Efficacy was assessed by measuring NLF depth at time intervals up to 12 months subjectively by blind and open clinical scoring using the Lemperle scale, and objectively using skin replicas and in vivo 3D imaging methods. Tissue characterization and dermal thickness were also assessed using radiofrequency ultrasonography and high-resolution ultrasound imaging, respectively.
The filler injection highly significantly decreased the depth of NLFs (p < 0.0001) at all time points, with an improvement of at least 1 grade in the Lemperle score in 77% and 89% of the subjects at 9 and 12 months, respectively. NLF volume measured on replicas and 3D images significantly decreased after injection and this improvement was maintained over 12 months.
This HA gel is well tolerated and provides a significant and long-lasting correction of moderate to severe NLFs, as objectively demonstrated by instrumental methods.
多种基于透明质酸(HA)的填充剂的疗效已通过半定量和定性方法得到证实,这些方法在临床实践中有用,但可靠性较差。
在9至12个月的随访期内客观评估一种HA凝胶治疗鼻唇沟(NLFs)的疗效。
共有47例中重度鼻唇沟成年患者接受了一或两次HA凝胶注射。通过使用Lemperle量表进行盲法和开放临床评分,在长达12个月的时间间隔内主观测量鼻唇沟深度来评估疗效,并使用皮肤复制品和体内3D成像方法进行客观评估。还分别使用射频超声和高分辨率超声成像评估组织特征和真皮厚度。
在所有时间点,填充剂注射均使鼻唇沟深度显著降低(p < 0.0001),在9个月和12个月时,分别有77%和89%的受试者Lemperle评分至少提高1级。注射后在复制品和3D图像上测量的鼻唇沟体积显著减小,且这种改善在12个月内持续存在。
这种HA凝胶耐受性良好,并能显著且持久地矫正中重度鼻唇沟,仪器方法已客观证实这一点。