Barakat Lamia P, Schwartz Lisa A, Salamon Katherine S, Radcliffe Jerilynn
The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2010 Oct;32(7):540-7. doi: 10.1097/MPH.0b013e3181e793f9.
The study had 2 aims---to determine the efficacy of a family-based cognitive-behavioral pain management intervention for adolescents with sickle cell disease (SCD) in (1) reducing pain and improving health-related variables and (2) improving psychosocial outcomes. Each adolescent and a family support person were randomly assigned to receive a brief pain intervention (PAIN) (n=27) or a disease education attention control intervention (DISEASE ED) (n=26) delivered at home. Assessment of primary pain and health-related variables (health service use, pain coping, pain-related hindrance of goals) and secondary psychosocial outcomes (disease knowledge, disease self-efficacy, and family communication) occurred at baseline (before randomization), postintervention, and 1-year follow-up. Change on outcomes did not differ significantly by group at either time point. When groups were combined in exploratory analyses, there was evidence of small to medium effects of intervention on health-related and psychosocial variables. Efforts to address barriers to participation and improve feasibility of psychosocial interventions for pediatric SCD are critical to advancing development of effective treatments for pain. Sample size was insufficient to adequately test efficacy, and analyses did not support this focused cognitive-behavioral pain management intervention in this sample of adolescents with SCD. Exploratory analyses suggest that comprehensive interventions, that address a broad range of skills related to disease management and adolescent health concerns, may be more effective in supporting teens during healthcare transition.
该研究有两个目标——确定针对镰状细胞病(SCD)青少年的家庭认知行为疼痛管理干预措施在(1)减轻疼痛和改善健康相关变量方面以及(2)改善心理社会结果方面的效果。每位青少年及其一名家庭支持人员被随机分配接受在家中进行的简短疼痛干预(PAIN)(n = 27)或疾病教育关注对照干预(DISEASE ED)(n = 26)。在基线(随机分组前)、干预后和1年随访时对主要疼痛和健康相关变量(医疗服务利用、疼痛应对、与疼痛相关的目标阻碍)以及次要心理社会结果(疾病知识、疾病自我效能和家庭沟通)进行评估。在两个时间点,各组在结果变化方面均无显著差异。在探索性分析中将各组合并时,有证据表明干预对健康相关和心理社会变量有小到中等程度的影响。解决参与障碍并提高儿科SCD心理社会干预措施可行性的努力对于推进疼痛有效治疗方法的发展至关重要。样本量不足以充分检验疗效,并且分析不支持在该镰状细胞病青少年样本中采用这种针对性的认知行为疼痛管理干预措施。探索性分析表明,解决与疾病管理和青少年健康问题相关的广泛技能的综合干预措施可能在医疗保健过渡期间对支持青少年更有效。