Fu Qian, Hu Su-Min, Yang Jia-Jia, Hao Xi-Juan, Zhu Bin, Wang Qian, Wu Zheng-Rong, Li Jin
School of Preclinical Medicine, Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Beijing 100029, China.
Zhongguo Gu Shang. 2010 Jul;23(7):524-8.
To compare the effects of Wujia Bugu decoction and Alendronate sodium on protecting bone and muscle loss of hindlimb unloaded rats lasting three weeks.
March to May, 2009, 40 male Wistar rats with age of 6-week, were randomized divided to four groups (10 rats in each group): hindlimb unloaded group treated with Chinese medicine (HUC), hindlimb unloaded group treated with alendronate sodium (HUA), control group (CON), as well as hindlimb unloaded group (HU). During the experiment, rats of HUC was given Wujia Bugu decoction (including the Ciwujia, Shudihuang, Huainiuxi, Muli, etc. with the concentration of 0.704 g/ml) 10 ml/kg weight once a day, HUA was given quantitative alendronate sodium slice dissolve suspension (0.9 mg/ml) once a week. CON and HU were given double-distilled water. The experiment lasted 4 weeks,from the second to the forth week, rats in HU, HUC, HUA were hindlimb unloaded. All rats were sacrificed at the fourth weekend, the content of Ca, P and the activation of ALP in serum, Bone mineral density (BMD) of humerus and femurs, Biomechanical property of tibia and humerus, as well as the weight index of biceps and sural muscles were measured.
Compared with CON, serum Ca of HU was significantly increased (P < 0.05), BMD, mechanical properties, muscle index of hindlimb were significantly reduce (P < 0.01), the serum Ca of HUA significantly increased (P < 0.05). Serum ALP of HUC was significantly higher than other three groups (P < 0.01). Compared with HU, femoral BMD of HUC and HUA significantly increased, tibial maximum load, maximum deflection and elastic load had increased tendency; calf muscle atrophy of HUC and HUA was alleviate 50% and 12.5% respectively (P > 0.05), humeral BMD had no significant difference, while the maximum deflection (P < 0.01) and elastic deflection (P < 0.05) in humerus of HUA were significantly lower.
Herbal prescription and alendronate sodium can effectively protect the bone and muscle loss of hindlimb unloaded rats, improve its mechanical structure. Herbal prescription has advantages of relieving mechanical properties change. The effects of Wujia Bugu decoction and alendronate sodium are similar in treating space weightlessness bone loss.
比较五加补骨汤与阿仑膦酸钠对后肢去负荷3周大鼠骨与肌肉丢失的影响。
2009年3月至5月,选取40只6周龄雄性Wistar大鼠,随机分为4组(每组10只):中药治疗后肢去负荷组(HUC)、阿仑膦酸钠治疗后肢去负荷组(HUA)、对照组(CON)以及后肢去负荷组(HU)。实验期间,HUC组大鼠每日给予五加补骨汤(含刺五加、熟地黄、怀牛膝、牡蛎等,浓度为0.704 g/ml)10 ml/kg体重,HUA组每周给予定量阿仑膦酸钠片溶解悬液(0.9 mg/ml)。CON组和HU组给予双蒸水。实验持续4周,从第2周至第4周,HU、HUC、HUA组大鼠后肢去负荷。所有大鼠在第4周末处死,检测血清钙、磷含量及碱性磷酸酶活性,测定肱骨和股骨的骨密度(BMD)、胫骨和肱骨的生物力学性能以及肱二头肌和腓肠肌的重量指数。
与CON组相比,HU组血清钙显著升高(P < 0.05),后肢骨密度、力学性能、肌肉指数显著降低(P < 0.01),HUA组血清钙显著升高(P < 0.05)。HUC组血清碱性磷酸酶显著高于其他三组(P < 0.01)。与HU组相比,HUC组和HUA组股骨骨密度显著增加,胫骨最大负荷、最大挠度和弹性负荷有增加趋势;HUC组和HUA组小腿肌肉萎缩分别减轻50%和12.5%(P > 0.05),肱骨骨密度无显著差异,而HUA组肱骨最大挠度(P < 0.01)和弹性挠度(P < 0.05)显著降低。
中药复方和阿仑膦酸钠能有效保护后肢去负荷大鼠的骨与肌肉丢失,改善其力学结构。中药复方在缓解力学性能改变方面具有优势。五加补骨汤与阿仑膦酸钠在治疗空间失重性骨质丢失方面效果相似。