Chetanneau A, Baum R P, Lehur P A, Liehn J C, Perkins A C, Bares R, Bourguet P, Herry J Y, Saccavini J C, Chatal J F
Centre René Gauducheau, Nantes, France.
Eur J Nucl Med. 1990;17(5):223-9. doi: 10.1007/BF00812361.
Six European nuclear medicine centres performed immunoscintigraphy first retrospectively in 34 patients using indium-111-labelled carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA)-specific and/or 19-9 F(ab')2 fragments. Results for sensitivity and specificity in tumour sites were 94% and 87%, respectively, for the pelvis and 73% and 100% for the extrahepatic abdomen. A second prospective series concerned 58 other patients previously operated on for colorectal adenocarcinoma (27 colon, 31 rectum). Two-thirds of these patients had a suspected recurrence signalled by an isolated rise in tumour markers, and 46 patients examined by immunoscintigraphy, X-ray computed tomography and ultrasonography were found to have a recurrence (a total of 62 tumour sites). Sensitivity and specificity with immunoscintigraphy were 90% and 97%, respectively, for the pelvis and 62% and 95% for the extrahepatic abdomen. For 29 patients injected with CEA-specific fragments, sensitivity was 90% and specificity 94% for the pelvis. For 25 patients injected with 19-9 fragments, pelvic sensitivity and specificity were 80% and 100%, respectively, whereas sensitivity for the extrahepatic abdomen was only 29% since several cases of peritoneal carcinosis were not visualized. In the prospective series, comparison of the three imaging techniques for all tumour sites (including liver and in 5 cases thorax) gave a sensitivity and specificity of 82% and 91%, respectively, for immunoscintigraphy, 52% and 95% for X-ray computed tomography and 59% and 100% for ultrasonography. These results thus confirm the advantage of using 111In-labelled CEA-specific or 19-9 to visualize and localize recurrences of colorectal cancer.
六个欧洲核医学中心首先对34例患者进行了回顾性免疫闪烁显像,使用铟-111标记的癌胚抗原(CEA)特异性和/或19-9 F(ab')2片段。肿瘤部位的敏感性和特异性结果分别为:骨盆处为94%和87%,肝外腹部为73%和100%。第二项前瞻性研究涉及另外58例曾接受过结肠直肠癌手术的患者(27例结肠癌,31例直肠癌)。这些患者中有三分之二因肿瘤标志物单独升高而怀疑复发,46例接受免疫闪烁显像、X线计算机断层扫描和超声检查的患者被发现有复发(共62个肿瘤部位)。免疫闪烁显像的敏感性和特异性分别为:骨盆处为90%和97%,肝外腹部为62%和95%。对于29例注射CEA特异性片段的患者,骨盆处的敏感性为90%,特异性为94%。对于25例注射19-9片段的患者,骨盆处的敏感性和特异性分别为80%和100%,而肝外腹部的敏感性仅为29%,因为几例腹膜癌未显影。在前瞻性研究系列中,对所有肿瘤部位(包括肝脏,5例包括胸部)的三种成像技术进行比较,免疫闪烁显像的敏感性和特异性分别为82%和91%,X线计算机断层扫描为52%和95%,超声检查为59%和100%。因此,这些结果证实了使用铟-111标记的CEA特异性或19-9来可视化和定位结肠直肠癌复发的优势。