D S Aruna, Rajesh G, Mohanty Vikrant Ranjan
Department of Public Health Dentistry, I.T.S Center for Dental Studies and Research, Muradnagar, District, India.
Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2010;11(2):539-43.
The Government of India issued an undertaking in the Supreme Court mandating pictorial health warnings (PHWs) on packages of tobacco products from 31st May, 2009 under " Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products Act " (COTPA) guidelines. This constitutes a key economic channel for educating people on devastating health impacts of deadly products within in a vivid and memorable way. Few studies have investigated PHWs on tobacco products marketed in India.
To assess met guidelines for pictorial health warnings under packaging and labeling rules on packages of collected tobacco products specified by COTPA.
Snowball/network sampling design was followed to obtain samples of 37 different tobacco brands, 18 in smoking form (12 cigarette, 6 bidi brands) and 19 in smokeless form (4 chewing tobacco, 11 Gutkha and 4 Khaini brands) marketed at retail outlets at Muradnagar. They were analyzed for their compliance with guidelines through checklist by one calibrated examiner.
PHWs were absent on packages of 5 tobacco brands. Fifteen tobacco brands had PHWs smaller than stipulated 40% of principal display area; 6 brands of bidis had PHWs on deceptive backgrounds, 3 of which were placed on a curved axis. Misleading descriptors and promotional messages were also present.
Locally marketed tobacco products were not compliant with packaging and labeling rules specified by COTPA. This highlights the need for more stringent implementation of COTPA guidelines to combat the ever-growing tobacco menace.
印度政府向最高法院做出承诺,根据《香烟及其他烟草制品法案》(COTPA)的指导方针,自2009年5月31日起,在烟草制品包装上强制使用图片健康警示(PHWs)。这是一项关键的经济渠道,能够以生动且令人难忘的方式向人们宣传致命烟草制品对健康的毁灭性影响。很少有研究调查印度市场上烟草制品的图片健康警示情况。
评估所收集的COTPA规定的烟草制品包装上的图片健康警示是否符合包装和标签规则的指导方针。
采用雪球/网络抽样设计,获取在穆拉德纳加尔零售店销售的37个不同烟草品牌的样本,其中18个为吸烟用形式(12个香烟品牌,6个比迪烟品牌),19个为无烟用形式(4个嚼烟品牌,11个古特卡品牌和4个卡伊尼品牌)。由一名经过校准的检查人员通过核对清单对其是否符合指导方针进行分析。
5个烟草品牌的包装上没有图片健康警示。15个烟草品牌的图片健康警示小于规定的主要展示面积的40%;6个比迪烟品牌的图片健康警示背景具有欺骗性,其中3个位于曲线上。还存在误导性描述和促销信息。
当地销售的烟草制品不符合COTPA规定的包装和标签规则。这凸显了更严格执行COTPA指导方针以应对日益严重的烟草威胁的必要性。