Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA.
Addiction. 2011 Feb;106(2):428-41. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2010.03135.x. Epub 2010 Oct 6.
The effectiveness of expert-led (EX) and train-the-trainer (TT) strategies was compared to a self-study approach (SS) for teaching clinicians motivational interviewing (MI).
Twelve community treatment programs were assigned randomly to the three conditions. EX and TT conditions used skill-building workshops and three monthly supervision sessions guided by treatment integrity ratings, performance feedback and coaching techniques. Trainers in TT were first trained and certified in MI and then prepared carefully to deliver the workshops and supervise MI at their programs. Clinicians in SS only received the training materials.
Licensed out-patient and residential addiction and mental health treatment programs in the US state of Connecticut were involved in the study.
Ninety-two clinicians who provided addiction treatment within these programs and had limited experience with MI participated in the study.
Primary outcomes were the clinicians' MI adherence and competence and the percentage of clinicians meeting clinical trial standards of MI performance. Assessments occurred at baseline, post-workshop, post-supervision and at 12-week follow-up.
The study found EX and TT, in comparison to SS, improved clinicians' adherence and competence significantly, with higher percentages of clinicians reaching clinical trial standards of MI performance and few differences between EX and TT.
This study supports the combined use of workshops and supervision to teach community program clinicians MI and suggests the train-the-trainer approach may be a feasible and effective strategy for disseminating empirically supported treatments.
比较专家主导(EX)和培训师培训(TT)策略与自学方法(SS)在教授临床医生动机访谈(MI)方面的效果。
将 12 个社区治疗项目随机分配到三个条件中。EX 和 TT 条件使用技能建设研讨会和三个每月监督会议,由治疗完整性评分、绩效反馈和辅导技巧指导。TT 中的培训师首先接受 MI 培训和认证,然后精心准备在他们的项目中提供研讨会和监督 MI。SS 中的临床医生仅收到培训材料。
美国康涅狄格州的许可门诊和住院成瘾和心理健康治疗项目参与了这项研究。
92 名在这些项目中提供成瘾治疗且 MI 经验有限的临床医生参与了这项研究。
主要结果是临床医生的 MI 依从性和能力以及达到 MI 表现临床试验标准的临床医生的百分比。评估在基线、研讨会后、监督后和 12 周随访时进行。
该研究发现,与 SS 相比,EX 和 TT 显著提高了临床医生的依从性和能力,达到 MI 表现临床试验标准的临床医生比例更高,EX 和 TT 之间几乎没有差异。
这项研究支持使用研讨会和监督相结合的方法来教授社区项目临床医生 MI,并表明培训师培训方法可能是传播经验支持的治疗方法的一种可行且有效的策略。