Neuroscience Statistics Research Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, 02114, USA.
IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2011 Apr;19(2):121-35. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2010.2086079. Epub 2010 Oct 11.
The ability to accurately infer functional connectivity between ensemble neurons using experimentally acquired spike train data is currently an important research objective in computational neuroscience. Point process generalized linear models and maximum likelihood estimation have been proposed as effective methods for the identification of spiking dependency between neurons. However, unfavorable experimental conditions occasionally results in insufficient data collection due to factors such as low neuronal firing rates or brief recording periods, and in these cases, the standard maximum likelihood estimate becomes unreliable. The present studies compares the performance of different statistical inference procedures when applied to the estimation of functional connectivity in neuronal assemblies with sparse spiking data. Four inference methods were compared: maximum likelihood estimation, penalized maximum likelihood estimation, using either l(2) or l(1) regularization, and hierarchical Bayesian estimation based on a variational Bayes algorithm. Algorithmic performances were compared using well-established goodness-of-fit measures in benchmark simulation studies, and the hierarchical Bayesian approach performed favorably when compared with the other algorithms, and this approach was then successfully applied to real spiking data recorded from the cat motor cortex. The identification of spiking dependencies in physiologically acquired data was encouraging, since their sparse nature would have previously precluded them from successful analysis using traditional methods.
使用实验获得的尖峰火车数据准确推断集合神经元之间的功能连接的能力目前是计算神经科学的一个重要研究目标。点过程广义线性模型和最大似然估计已被提出作为识别神经元之间的尖峰依赖性的有效方法。然而,不利的实验条件偶尔会由于神经元发射率低或记录时间短等因素导致数据采集不足,在这种情况下,标准的最大似然估计变得不可靠。本研究比较了不同统计推断方法在稀疏尖峰数据的神经元集合功能连接估计中的性能。比较了四种推断方法:最大似然估计、惩罚最大似然估计、使用 l(2)或 l(1)正则化,以及基于变分贝叶斯算法的分层贝叶斯估计。在基准模拟研究中使用成熟的拟合优度度量标准比较算法性能,分层贝叶斯方法的性能优于其他算法,然后成功地将其应用于从猫运动皮层记录的真实尖峰数据。生理获得的数据中尖峰依赖性的识别令人鼓舞,因为它们的稀疏性质以前会阻止它们使用传统方法进行成功的分析。