Department of Orthodontics, "Sacred Heart" Catholic University, Roma, Italy.
Prog Orthod. 2010;11(2):92-7. doi: 10.1016/j.pio.2010.04.002. Epub 2010 May 4.
The aim of the study was to analyse the attractiveness of modifications of lip, nose or chin positions on profile photographs.
A profile digital photograph was randomly selected among pictures of 50 models participating to a beauty contest and then reviewed by 10 orthodontists and 10 laypersons who unanimously rated the profile as attractive. The original picture (O) was modified so as to create protrusion and retrusion of the lips of 2,4 and 6mm, thus generating 6 new pictures (O-6, O-4, O-2, O+2, O+4, O+6). From the original picture 7 new pictures were generated: (N) with the nose protruded of 6mm and its combinations with lips protrusion and retrusion (N-6, N-4, N-2, N+2, N+4, N+6). In the same way, picture (C) was created with the chin protruded of 6mm and 6 combinations of protruded chin with protruded and retruded lips were generated (C-6, C-4, C -2, C+2, C+4, C+6). 15 orthodontists and 15 laypersons were asked to rate all the 21 pictures on Visual Analogue Scales (VAS).
The original picture reported the highest VAS scores. Comparing the series "C" and "N", the pictures with Nose protrusion show higher VAS scores if compared with pictures with chin protrusion (p<.05). When nose or chin protrusion is present, the pictures that shows lip protrusion (N+2, C+2) reported higher VAS scores (p<.05).
In cases of nose or chin protrusion, a compensatory lip protrusion improves the profile attractiveness. Nose protrusion seems to be more tolerated than a similar amount of chin protrusion.
本研究旨在分析唇部、鼻部或颏部位置变化对面部侧貌照片吸引力的影响。
随机选取 50 名选美模特的一张侧貌数字化照片,由 10 名正畸医生和 10 名非专业人士对该照片进行评估,他们一致认为该照片具有吸引力。原始照片(O)的唇部分别向外突出 2、4、6mm,生成 6 张新的图片(O-6、O-4、O-2、O+2、O+4、O+6)。原始照片还生成了 7 张新的鼻部突出图片(N),突出距离为 6mm,并与唇部突出和回缩相结合(N-6、N-4、N-2、N+2、N+4、N+6)。同样地,颏部突出 6mm 生成图片(C),并与突出和回缩的唇部生成 6 张组合图片(C-6、C-4、C-2、C+2、C+4、C+6)。15 名正畸医生和 15 名非专业人士对所有 21 张图片进行视觉模拟评分(VAS)。
原始图片的 VAS 评分最高。比较“C”系列和“N”系列,当存在鼻部突出时,与颏部突出相比,鼻部突出的图片 VAS 评分更高(p<.05)。当存在鼻部或颏部突出时,唇部突出的图片(N+2、C+2)VAS 评分更高(p<.05)。
在存在鼻部或颏部突出的情况下,唇部的代偿性突出可改善面部侧貌的吸引力。鼻部突出比类似程度的颏部突出更易被接受。