Horrell Timothy, El-Baz Ayman, Baruth Joshua, Tasman Allan, Sokhadze Guela, Stewart Christopher, Sokhadze Estate
Department of Bioengineering, Speed School of Engineering, University of Louisville, Louisville, Kentucky.
J Neurother. 2010 Jul;14(3):195-216. doi: 10.1080/10874208.2010.501498.
Preoccupation with drug and drug-related items is a typical characteristic of cocaine addicted individuals. It has been shown in multiple accounts that prolonged drug use has a profound effect on the EEG recordings of drug addicts when compared to controls during cue reactivity tests. Cue reactivity refers to a phenomenon in which individuals with a history of drug abuse exhibit excessive psychophysiological responses to cues associated with their drug of choice. One of the aims of this pilot study was to determine the presence of an attentional bias to preferentially process drug-related cues using evoked and induced gamma reactivity measures in cocaine addicts before and after biobehavioral treatment based on neurofeedback. Another aim was to show that central SMR amplitude increase and frontal theta control is possible in an experimental outpatient drug users group over 12 neurofeedback sessions. METHOD: Ten current cocaine abusers participated in this pilot research study using neurofeedback combined with Motivational Interviewing sessions. Eight of them completed all planned pre- and post -neurofeedback cue reactivity tests with event-related EEG recording and clinical evaluations. Cue reactivity test represented a visual oddball task with images from the International Affective Picture System and drug-related pictures. Evoked and induced gamma responses to target and non-target drug cues were analyzed using wavelet analysis. RESULTS: Outpatient subjects with cocaine addiction completed the biobehavioral intervention and successfully increased SMR while keeping theta practically unchanged in 12 sessions of neurofeedback training. The addition of Motivational Interviewing helped retain patients in the study. Clinical evaluations immediately after completion of the treatment showed decreased self-reports on depression and stress scores, and urine tests collaborated reports of decreased use of cocaine and marijuana. Effects of neurofeedback resulted in a lower EEG gamma reactivity to drug-related images in a post-neurofeedback cue reactivity test. In particular, evoked gamma showed decreases in power to non-target and to a lesser extent target drug-related cues at all topographies (left, right, frontal, parietal, medial, inferior); while induced gamma power decreased globally to both target and non-target drug cues. Our findings supported our hypothesis that gamma band cue reactivity measures are sufficiently sensitive functional outcomes of neurofeedback treatment. Both evoked and induced gamma measures were found capable to detect changes in responsiveness to both target and non-target drug cues. CONCLUSION: Our study emphasizes the utility of cognitive neuroscience methods based on EEG gamma band measures for the assessment of the functional outcomes of neurofeedback-based biobehavioral interventions for cocaine use disorders. This approach may have significant potential for identifying both physiological and clinical markers of treatment progress. The results confirmed our prediction that EEG changes achieved with neurofeedback training will be accompanied by positive EEG outcomes in a cue reactivity and clinical improvements.
对毒品及与毒品相关物品的过度关注是可卡因成瘾者的典型特征。多项研究表明,与对照组相比,长期吸毒对吸毒者在线索反应测试中的脑电图记录有深远影响。线索反应是指有药物滥用史的个体对与其首选药物相关的线索表现出过度的心理生理反应的现象。这项初步研究的目的之一是,使用基于神经反馈的生物行为治疗前后的诱发和诱发伽马反应测量方法,确定可卡因成瘾者是否存在优先处理与毒品相关线索的注意力偏差。另一个目的是表明,在一个实验性门诊吸毒者群体中,经过12次神经反馈训练,中枢感觉运动节律(SMR)振幅增加和额叶θ波控制是可行的。
10名当前的可卡因滥用者参与了这项使用神经反馈结合动机性访谈的初步研究。其中8人完成了所有计划的神经反馈前后线索反应测试,包括事件相关脑电图记录和临床评估。线索反应测试是一项视觉oddball任务,使用来自国际情感图片系统的图像和与毒品相关的图片。使用小波分析对目标和非目标毒品线索的诱发和诱发伽马反应进行分析。
患有可卡因成瘾的门诊受试者完成了生物行为干预,并在12次神经反馈训练中成功增加了SMR,同时使θ波基本保持不变。动机性访谈有助于留住研究中的患者。治疗结束后立即进行的临床评估显示,抑郁和压力评分的自我报告有所下降,尿液检测也证实了可卡因和大麻使用减少的报告。神经反馈的效果导致在神经反馈后线索反应测试中,对与毒品相关图像的脑电图伽马反应性降低。特别是诱发伽马显示,在所有地形(左、右、额叶、顶叶、内侧、下侧),对非目标以及在较小程度上对目标毒品相关线索的功率下降;而诱发伽马功率对目标和非目标毒品线索整体下降。我们的研究结果支持了我们的假设,即伽马波段线索反应测量是神经反馈治疗足够敏感的功能结果。发现诱发和诱发伽马测量都能够检测对目标和非目标毒品线索反应性的变化。
我们的研究强调了基于脑电图伽马波段测量的认知神经科学方法在评估基于神经反馈的生物行为干预对可卡因使用障碍的功能结果方面的实用性。这种方法在识别治疗进展的生理和临床标志物方面可能具有重大潜力。结果证实了我们的预测,即神经反馈训练实现的脑电图变化将伴随着线索反应中的积极脑电图结果和临床改善。