Kunze M, Seidel H J, Stübe G
Klinik für Innere Medizin, Bereich Neuropsychiatrie, Bezirkskrankenhauses Suhl.
Z Gesamte Inn Med. 1990 Oct 15;45(20):625-7.
At a comparison among 5 therapy methods the small psychotherapy with a success-rate of 74% is high-significantly more prosperous than the other examined methods. The acupuncture with 31% long-term success is significantly superior to the pseudoacupuncture (17.2%). The papaverine therapy results in a long-lasting status free of symptoms in 17.2% of the patients and is significantly different from the results of the papaverine-placebo-therapy (0%). Distinct differences in the success-rates of the small psychotherapy with different therapists prove the role of the personality and the perfection in mastering the methods with psychotherapeutic procedures. Comparable differences between the examiners were not found among the effects of a spasmolytic therapy.
在对5种治疗方法进行比较时，成功率为74%的小剂量心理治疗比其他所研究的方法显著更有效。长期成功率为31%的针灸疗法明显优于假针灸疗法（17.2%）。罂粟碱疗法使17.2%的患者产生持久的无症状状态，且与罂粟碱安慰剂疗法的结果（0%）有显著差异。不同治疗师进行小剂量心理治疗的成功率存在明显差异，这证明了个性以及在掌握心理治疗程序方法方面的熟练程度所起的作用。在解痉疗法的效果方面，未发现检查者之间存在类似差异。
