CIHR-SHRF Applied Chair in Health Services & Policy Research, Canadian Centre for Health & Safety in Agriculture, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK, Canada S7N 0W8.
Maturitas. 2011 Jan;68(1):17-33. doi: 10.1016/j.maturitas.2010.09.008. Epub 2010 Oct 30.
The purpose of this review is to critically evaluate the available evidence from the published scientific literature on dementia care and service provision in rural and remote settings from the perspective of formal/paid caregiving, in order to assess the current state of knowledge, identify policy and practice implications, and make recommendations for future research.
A systematic review of the literature indexed in ISI Web of Knowledge, PsychInfo, Medline, Healthstar, CINAHL, EMBASE, and Sociological Abstracts was conducted. Data were extracted from papers meeting inclusion criteria: peer-reviewed papers that focused on dementia or Alzheimer's disease (AD), examined care or service provision in relation to persons with AD or dementia, and relevant to rural or remote care or services.
The search identified 872 articles for review, reduced to 72 after removing duplicates and articles not meeting criteria. Of the 72 remaining, 46 are included in this current review focusing on formal or paid care. A future review will focus on the 26 studies on informal/unpaid care. Six themes that correspond to the current state of knowledge in rural dementia care in the 46 included studies were: diagnostic processes, service provision, service models and programs, staff education and support needs, use of technology, and long-term care.
Despite the growing body of evidence over the 20 years covered by this review, much of the research is descriptive and/or based on small sample sizes, and distributed across the care continuum. Hence the body of evidence on which to base policy and program decisions remains limited. More research is needed that would support the development of comprehensive rural dementia care models.
本综述旨在从正规/有偿护理的角度,批判性地评估发表的科学文献中关于农村和偏远地区痴呆症护理和服务提供的现有证据,以评估当前的知识状况,确定政策和实践意义,并为未来的研究提出建议。
对 ISI Web of Knowledge、PsychInfo、Medline、Healthstar、CINAHL、EMBASE 和 Sociological Abstracts 索引的文献进行了系统回顾。从符合纳入标准的论文中提取数据:同行评议的论文,重点关注痴呆症或阿尔茨海默病(AD),研究与 AD 或痴呆症患者相关的护理或服务提供情况,以及与农村或偏远地区护理或服务相关的论文。
搜索确定了 872 篇文章进行审查,在去除重复和不符合标准的文章后,减少到 72 篇。在剩下的 72 篇中,有 46 篇被纳入本综述,重点关注正规或有偿护理。未来的综述将集中在 26 项关于非正式/无偿护理的研究上。在纳入的 46 项研究中,有六个主题与农村痴呆症护理的当前知识状况相对应:诊断过程、服务提供、服务模式和方案、员工教育和支持需求、技术使用以及长期护理。
尽管本综述涵盖的 20 年来证据不断增加,但大部分研究都是描述性的,或者基于小样本量,分布在整个护理连续体中。因此,可供制定政策和计划决策的证据仍然有限。需要进行更多的研究,以支持综合农村痴呆症护理模式的发展。