Universita Cattolica and Fondazione Santa Lucia IRCCS, Rome, Italy.
Cogn Neuropsychol. 2006;23(1):110-34. doi: 10.1080/02643290500202730.
Early cognitive models of spelling assumed that orthographic word representations are linear, ordered sequences of abstract letter identities (graphemes), activated only by word meaning information, and in some cases proposed that activating phonological information is a necessary stage of the spelling process. Over the past 20 years, studies on dysgraphia have shown that orthographic representations are autonomous from phonological representations and, just like the latter, are directly activated from semantics. The selection of an orthographic form for output relies on the convergence of activation from lexical-semantic information and from sublexical phoneme-grapheme conversion procedures. In addition, it is increasingly clear that orthographic representations are multidimensional objects that separately represent the graphosyllabic structure (or perhaps the nucleus/non-nucleus positions) of the target, and the identity, the CV status, and the quantity (doubling) of each grapheme. In spelling, the structure of orthographic knowledge and the mechanisms involved in processing serial order interact in complex ways and constrain performance accuracy. Further research is needed to clarify some critical issues: We need to specify in greater detail the mechanisms involved in the interaction between meaning and sublexical information; we must consider the possibility that orthographic representations have texture, in addition to structure; we must provide explicit hypotheses on the mechanisms that process orthographic knowledge; and we must gain a better understanding of the interaction between structure and serial order.
早期的拼写认知模型假设,拼写字面的表示是线性的、有序的抽象字母身份(字形)序列,仅由词义信息激活,在某些情况下还提出,激活语音信息是拼写过程的必要阶段。在过去的 20 年里,对失写症的研究表明,拼写字面的表示与语音表示是自主的,就像后者一样,直接从语义中激活。输出的拼写字面形式的选择依赖于从词汇语义信息和亚词汇音素-字形转换过程的激活的收敛。此外,越来越明显的是,拼写字面的表示是多维对象,分别表示目标的语素音节结构(或者可能是核/非核位置),以及每个字形的身份、CV 状态和数量(加倍)。在拼写中,拼写字面知识的结构和涉及处理序列顺序的机制以复杂的方式相互作用,限制了性能的准确性。需要进一步的研究来澄清一些关键问题:我们需要更详细地说明涉及意义和亚词汇信息之间相互作用的机制;我们必须考虑到除了结构之外,拼写字面的表示还具有纹理的可能性;我们必须对处理拼写字面知识的机制提出明确的假设;我们必须更好地理解结构和序列顺序之间的相互作用。