Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Medical University of Vienna , Austria.
Clin EEG Neurosci. 2010 Oct;41(4):203-10. doi: 10.1177/155005941004100407.
Earlier investigations suggested an involvement of the right hemisphere and the left prefrontal cortex (PFC) in the pathogenesis of depression. This paper presents our own electroencephalographic (EEG) topography and low-resolution brain electromagnetic tomography (LORETA) data obtained in unmedicated depressed patients, and the effects of two representative drugs of non-sedative and sedative antidepressants, i.e., citalopram (CIT) and imipramine (IMI), as compared with placebo in normal subjects. Sixty female menopausal syndrome patients with the diagnosis of a depressive episode without psychotic symptoms as well as 30 healthy controls were investigated. Concerning the effects of antidepressants, normal healthy subjects received single oral doses of 20 mg CIT, 75 mg IMI and placebo p.o. A 3-min vigilance-controlled EEG and a 4-min resting EEG was recorded pre- and post-drug administration and analyzed by means of EEG mapping and LORETA. In the EEG mapping, depressed patients demonstrated a decrease in absolute power in all frequency bands, an augmentation of relative delta/theta and beta and a decrease in alpha activity as well as a slowing of the delta/theta centroid and an acceleration of the alpha and beta centroid, which suggests vigilance decrements. In the alpha asymmetry index, they showed right frontal hyper- and left frontal hypoactivation correlated with the Hamilton Depression Score (HAMD). LORETA predominantly revealed decreased power in the theta and alpha-1 frequency band. Negative correlations between theta power and the HAMD were observed in the ventro-medial PFC, the bilateral rostral anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and the left insular cortex; between alpha-1 power and the HAMD in the right PFC. In the EEG mapping of antidepressants, 20 mg CIT showed mainly activating, 75 mg IMI partly sedative properties. LORETA revealed that CIT increased alpha-2, beta-1, beta-2 and beta-3 power more over the right than over the left hemisphere. However, also a left temporal and frontal delta increase was observed. In conclusion, EEG topography and tomography of depressed menopausal patients demonstrated a right frontal hyper- and left frontal hypoactivation in the alpha asymmetry index as well as a vigilance decrease, with a right-hemispheric preponderance. Within antidepressants at least 2 subtypes may be distinguished from the electrophysiological point of view, a non-sedative and a sedative. LORETA identifies cerebral generators responsible for the pathogenesis of depression as well as for the mode of action of antidepressants.
先前的研究表明,右半球和左前额叶皮层(PFC)参与了抑郁症的发病机制。本文介绍了我们在未经治疗的抑郁症患者中获得的脑电图(EEG)地形和低分辨率脑电磁断层扫描(LORETA)数据,以及两种非镇静和镇静抗抑郁药,即西酞普兰(CIT)和丙咪嗪(IMI)的作用,与正常受试者中的安慰剂进行了比较。研究了 60 名患有非精神病性抑郁发作的更年期综合征女性患者和 30 名健康对照者。关于抗抑郁药的作用,正常健康受试者口服单剂量 20mg CIT、75mg IMI 和安慰剂。给药前后记录 3 分钟警觉控制 EEG 和 4 分钟休息 EEG,并通过 EEG 映射和 LORETA 进行分析。在 EEG 映射中,抑郁症患者在所有频段的绝对功率均降低,相对 delta/theta 和 beta 增加,alpha 活动减少,delta/theta 质心减慢,alpha 和 beta 质心加速,提示警觉度降低。在 alpha 不对称指数中,他们表现出右额前区过度兴奋和左额前区兴奋不足,与汉密尔顿抑郁量表(HAMD)评分相关。LORETA 主要显示 theta 和 alpha-1 频段的功率降低。在腹内侧前额叶皮质、双侧额前扣带皮质(ACC)和左侧岛叶皮质中,theta 功率与 HAMD 呈负相关;在右前额叶皮质中,alpha-1 功率与 HAMD 呈负相关。在抗抑郁药的 EEG 映射中,20mg CIT 主要表现为激活作用,75mg IMI 部分具有镇静作用。LORETA 显示 CIT 增加了右半球比左半球更多的 alpha-2、beta-1、beta-2 和 beta-3 功率。然而,也观察到左颞叶和额叶 delta 增加。总之,更年期抑郁症患者的脑电图地形学和断层扫描显示,在 alpha 不对称指数中存在右额前区过度兴奋和左额前区兴奋不足以及警觉性降低,右半球优势。从电生理角度来看,至少可以区分出两种抗抑郁药,一种是非镇静剂,另一种是镇静剂。LORETA 确定了导致抑郁症发病机制以及抗抑郁药作用模式的脑发生器。