Identification of staphylococci by Phoenix: validation of a new protocol and comparison with Vitek 2.

Because of their frequent isolation in the routine laboratory and their increasing clinical significance, fast and accurate species identification of staphylococci may be required; this can only be achieved by automated systems. A total of 147 clinical isolates (52 Staphylococcus aureus, 50 Staphylococcus epidermidis, and 45 other coagulase-negative staphylococci [CoNS]) were first identified by molecular methodology and then comparatively tested by Vitek 2 (new colorimetric identification card) and Phoenix using the novel 0.25 McFarland and the standard 0.50 McFarland inoculum protocols. All S. aureus isolates were accurately identified. Vitek 2 identified correctly all S. epidermidis and 93.3% of the other CoNS, whereas the respective rates were 86% and 82.2% for Phoenix's standard and 92% and 82.2% for the novel protocol. It appears that both systems provide excellent identification of S. aureus, but Vitek 2 recognizes CoNS species more accurately than Phoenix. The 0.25 McFarland protocol does not improve system performance.