Faculty of Nursing, Cairo University, Egypt.
Nurse Educ Pract. 2011 Mar;11(2):93-8. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2010.11.012. Epub 2010 Dec 17.
The aim of this study was to explore the learning experience of Egyptian male student nurses during attending maternity nursing clinical course at Cairo University Maternity Hospital.
A descriptive design was utilized for collecting the data that are necessary to answer the research question; both quantitative and qualitative data were collected using a semi- structured interview scale. A total of 60 students who just finished the clinic maternity course in college of Nursing, Cairo University were recruited for the study.
More than half of the sample (66.7%) preferred to deal with males rather than female patients. A number of stressors were reported by students during their clinical training such as: high requirement pertained to clinical area training (55%); unfavorable attitude of the clinical instructors (11%); and refusal of women to receive care by a male student nurse (34%). The most embarrassing procedures for the students were: abdominal examination, breast examination and perineal care. The most interesting procedures were assessment of the newborn, attending cesarean section and providing mother classes for mother in both antenatal clinic and postpartum unit, 53% of the students reported that the women were dealing with them with restrictions, while (25%) reported that women refused to deal with them during labor, 50% described their experience in maternity nursing clinical course as useful, while (18%) described it as interesting and (39%) described it as very embarrassing for male student nurses. Among the suggestions made by students to modify their clinical experience were: 1) substituting clinical training by the skill lab for male students and also adding clinical experience in andrology that refers to the medical specialty that deals with male health, particularly relating to the problems of the male reproductive system and urological problems (76%); 2) teaming with a female student during the clinical area (50%).
Based on the study findings, re-planning of some of the clinical rotations of Maternity Nursing to include substitute clinical experience for the male student should be considered. Furthermore, developing strategies to change male student's attitude toward child-bearing experience and fatherhood is crucial. Finally, male students should be oriented to and encouraged to identify with role model of male obstetricians.
本研究旨在探讨埃及男护生在开罗大学妇产医院参加母婴护理临床课程的学习体验。
采用描述性设计收集回答研究问题所需的数据;使用半结构化访谈量表收集定量和定性数据。共招募了 60 名刚在开罗大学护理学院完成临床妇产课程的学生参加研究。
超过一半的样本(66.7%)更喜欢与男性患者而不是女性患者打交道。学生在临床培训期间报告了一些压力源,例如:临床区域培训要求高(55%);临床教师态度不佳(11%);以及女性拒绝由男护生提供护理(34%)。学生最尴尬的操作是:腹部检查、乳房检查和会阴护理。最有趣的操作是评估新生儿、参加剖宫产和在产前门诊和产后病房为母亲提供母亲班,53%的学生报告说,女性对他们有限制,而(25%)报告说女性在分娩时拒绝与他们打交道,50%的学生将他们在母婴护理临床课程中的经历描述为有用,而(18%)将其描述为有趣,(39%)将其描述为男护生非常尴尬。学生提出的修改临床经验的建议包括:1)为男学生替代临床培训技能实验室,以及增加男性健康医学专业的临床经验,特别是涉及男性生殖系统和泌尿科问题(76%);2)与女学生在临床区域合作(50%)。
根据研究结果,应考虑重新规划母婴护理的一些临床轮转,为男护生提供替代临床经验。此外,制定改变男护生对生育体验和父性态度的策略至关重要。最后,应引导男学生并鼓励他们认同男产科医生的榜样。