Silva L, Miguel Eugenio De, Peiteado Diana, Villalba Alejandro, Mola Martin, Pinto Josã, Ventura Francisco S
Rheumatology Department, Hospital de São João, Universidade do Porto, Portugal.
Acta Reumatol Port. 2010 Oct-Dec;35(5):466-74.
Despite its relative high prevalence,potential devastating clinical consequences and socio-economic impact, the existence of effective drugs to treat it, and the well recognised direct relation between acute flares and treatment interruptions and its resumption, gout is still often considered the chronic disease with the worst rate of adherence to therapy. The reason for this is unknown. We proposed to thoroughly evaluate a subgroup of patients, aiming at identifying the clinical features predictive of non-compliance, and 5 different ways to assess those.
We analysed a number of clinical, analytical and ultrasound data relating to 34 gout patients (according to the Wallace-ARA diagnostic criteria for gout 1977 and the EULAR recommendations for gout diagnosis 2006), which were followed in a specialized rheumatology consultation as part of an ongoing study for ultrasound validation in gout. To assess non-compliance, we compared the prevalence of each one of these clinical features with 5 outcomes (2 of which related to "non-compliance": self-report of non-adherence to therapy and missing consultation, and 3 other outcomes related to "non-response": gout flare(s), final serum uric acid (sUA) ≥ 6 mg/dL, and no sonographic improvement) registered during a 1 year of follow-up assessment.
We have found an association between younger age, higher body mass index, previous treatment with urate lowering drugs, self-report of previous non-compliance, nephrolithiasis and hyperuricosuria and the "outcomes of non-compliance". These patients tended to be less often treated with NSAID and allopurinol, and more often treated with corticosteroid and benzbromarone during the 1 year follow-up. They have also presented higher rate of gout flares and final sUA. Evaluating the 3 "outcomes of non-response", we have noticed a tendency for association with long disease duration, self-report of previous non-compliance (frequently attributed to gout flare), higher initial sUA and kidney failure. These patients tended to be less often treated with NSAID, and more often treated with allopurinol. Gout flare correlated to self-report of non-compliance and no sonographic improvement. Sonographic non response also correlated to higher final sUA.
This study shows an association between some clinical features and non-compliance, but above all, and unlike the majority of other studies, it has found a correlation between non-compliance with possible causes of worst response or lower rate of treatment, such as hyperuricosuria, nephrolithiasis, kidney failure, and contraindication for NSAID treatment. The data which is based on a comprehensive and detailed clinical assessment, might point out hidden elements, which might go beyond the visible non-compliance, contributing to the frequent lack of control of the disease.
尽管痛风相对高发,具有潜在的严重临床后果和社会经济影响,存在有效的治疗药物,且急性发作与治疗中断及恢复之间的直接关系已得到充分认识,但痛风仍常被认为是治疗依从性最差的慢性病。其原因尚不清楚。我们提议对一组患者进行全面评估,旨在确定预测不依从的临床特征以及评估这些特征的5种不同方法。
我们分析了34例痛风患者(根据1977年Wallace-ARA痛风诊断标准和2006年欧洲抗风湿病联盟(EULAR)痛风诊断建议)的一些临床、分析和超声数据,这些患者在专门的风湿病门诊接受随访,作为一项正在进行的痛风超声验证研究的一部分。为了评估不依从情况,我们将这些临床特征中的每一项的患病率与在1年随访评估期间记录的5种结果(其中2种与“不依从”相关:自我报告的治疗不依从和错过会诊,另外3种结果与“无反应”相关:痛风发作、最终血清尿酸(sUA)≥6mg/dL和超声无改善)进行了比较。
我们发现年龄较小、体重指数较高、既往使用降尿酸药物治疗、既往自我报告的不依从、肾结石和高尿酸尿症与“不依从结果”之间存在关联。在1年随访期间,这些患者使用非甾体抗炎药(NSAID)和别嘌醇治疗的频率较低,而使用皮质类固醇和苯溴马隆治疗的频率较高。他们的痛风发作率和最终sUA也较高。在评估3种“无反应结果”时,我们注意到与病程长、既往自我报告的不依从(常归因于痛风发作)、初始sUA较高和肾衰竭之间存在关联趋势。这些患者使用NSAID治疗的频率较低,而使用别嘌醇治疗的频率较高。痛风发作与自我报告的不依从和超声无改善相关。超声无反应也与较高的最终sUA相关。
本研究显示了一些临床特征与不依从之间的关联,但最重要的是,与大多数其他研究不同的是,它发现了不依从与反应最差或治疗率较低的可能原因之间的相关性,如高尿酸尿症、肾结石、肾衰竭以及NSAID治疗的禁忌证。基于全面详细临床评估的数据可能指出了一些隐藏因素,这些因素可能超出了明显的不依从情况,导致疾病频繁缺乏控制。