Forbes Jonathan A, Chambless Lola B, Smith Jason G, Wushensky Curtis A, Lebow Richard L, Alvarez JoAnn, Pearson Matthew M
Department of Neurosurgery, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee, USA.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2011 Feb;7(2):165-74. doi: 10.3171/2010.11.PEDS10312.
The question of whether to obtain routine or selective preoperative imaging of the neuraxis in pediatric patients with cerebellar neoplasms remains a controversial topic. Staging of the neuraxis is generally considered beneficial in patients with neoplasms associated with an elevated risk of leptomeningeal dissemination (LD). When these studies are obtained preoperatively, there is a decrease in the number of false-positive images related to debris in the immediate postoperative period. Additionally, knowledge of the extent of spread has the potential to affect the risk/benefit analysis of aggressive resection. Although the majority of pediatric neurosurgeons surveyed choose to obtain selective preoperative imaging of the neuraxis in cases of cerebellar neoplasms "with findings suggestive of high-grade pathology," an evidence-based protocol in the literature is lacking. The goal of this study was to assess radiological characteristics of tumors with an elevated risk of LD and identify a method to help guide preoperative imaging of the neuraxis.
The authors first reviewed the literature to gain an appreciation of the risk of LD of pediatric cerebellar neoplasms based on underlying histopathology and/or grade. Available evidence indicates preoperative imaging of the neuraxis in patients with Grade I tumors to be of questionable utility. In contrast, evidence suggested that preoperative imaging of the neuraxis in patients with Grades II-IV neoplasms was clinically warranted. The authors then evaluated an extensive base of neuroradiological literature to identify possible MR imaging and/or CT findings with the potential to differentiate Grade I from higher-grade neoplasms in pediatric patients. They analyzed the preoperative radiological findings in 50 pediatric patients who had undergone craniotomy for resection of cerebellar neoplasms at Vanderbilt Children's Hospital since 2003 with reference to 7 chosen radiological criteria. Logistic regression models were fit using radiological features to determine the best predictors of Grades II-IV tumors. Receiver operating characteristic methods were used to identify diagnostic properties of the best predictors.
The relative T2 signal intensity (RT2SI), an indirect measure of the water content of the solid component of the tumor, was best able to identify neoplasms with an elevated risk of LD. An RT2SI value of 0.71 was selected by the authors as the best operating point on the curve. Of the 31 neoplasms retrospectively designated as hypointense T2-weighted lesions (RT2SI ≤ 0.71), 30 (97%) were Grade II or higher. All medulloblastomas, ependymomas, and high-grade (Grades III and IV) neoplasms were hypointense T2-weighted lesions. Of the 19 T2-weighted hyperintense neoplasms (RT2SI > 0.71), 16 (84%) were Grade I and 3 were Grade II.
Measurement of the RT2SI can help predict Grade II-IV tumors at an elevated risk of leptomeningeal spread and guide staging of the neuraxis. Pediatric patients with cerebellar neoplasms found to have an RT2SI of less than or equal to 0.71 are recommended for neuraxis imaging prior to surgery.
对于患有小脑肿瘤的儿科患者,是否进行常规或选择性术前神经轴成像仍是一个有争议的话题。对于伴有软脑膜播散(LD)风险升高的肿瘤患者,神经轴分期通常被认为是有益的。当这些检查在术前进行时,与术后早期碎片相关的假阳性图像数量会减少。此外,了解扩散范围有可能影响积极切除的风险/收益分析。尽管大多数接受调查的儿科神经外科医生选择在小脑肿瘤“有提示高级别病理特征”的情况下进行选择性术前神经轴成像,但文献中缺乏基于证据的方案。本研究的目的是评估LD风险升高的肿瘤的放射学特征,并确定一种有助于指导术前神经轴成像的方法。
作者首先回顾文献,以了解基于潜在组织病理学和/或分级的儿科小脑肿瘤LD风险。现有证据表明,I级肿瘤患者术前进行神经轴成像的效用存疑。相比之下,有证据表明,II-IV级肿瘤患者术前进行神经轴成像是临床上必要的。然后,作者评估了大量神经放射学文献,以确定可能有助于区分儿科患者I级与高级别肿瘤的磁共振成像(MR)和/或计算机断层扫描(CT)表现。他们参照7项选定的放射学标准,分析了自2003年以来在范德比尔特儿童医院接受小脑肿瘤切除术的50例儿科患者的术前放射学表现。使用放射学特征拟合逻辑回归模型以确定II-IV级肿瘤的最佳预测指标。采用受试者工作特征方法确定最佳预测指标的诊断特性。
相对T2信号强度(RT2SI),即肿瘤实体成分含水量的间接测量指标,最能识别LD风险升高的肿瘤。作者选择RT2SI值0.71作为曲线上的最佳操作点。在31个回顾性判定为T2加权低信号病变(RT2SI≤0.71)的肿瘤中,30个(97%)为II级或更高级别。所有髓母细胞瘤、室管膜瘤和高级别(III级和IV级)肿瘤均为T2加权低信号病变。在19个T2加权高信号肿瘤(RT2SI>0.71)中,16个(84%)为I级,3个为II级。
RT2SI测量有助于预测软脑膜播散风险升高的II-IV级肿瘤,并指导神经轴分期。对于RT2SI小于或等于0.71的患有小脑肿瘤的儿科患者,建议在手术前进行神经轴成像。