Department of Archaeology, Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts, 10 000 Zagreb, Croatia.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2011 Jun;145(2):270-81. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.21491. Epub 2011 Mar 1.
In order to test to what degree Schmorl's nodes (SN), osteophytosis of the vertebral bodies (VO), and osteoarthritis of the articular facets (OA) are useful indicators of activity-related stress, an analysis of their frequencies and severity of expression was conducted in two early Modern period skeletal samples from Croatia--Koprivno and Sisak. Historic and contemporary ethnographic sources suggest that living conditions were more demanding in Koprivno, and that a sexual division of labor existed in both populations. A total of 2,552 vertebral bodies (990 from Koprivno and 1,562 from Sisak) and 5,186 articular facets (2,135 from Koprivno and 3,051 from Sisak) were analyzed. Koprivno exhibits significantly higher total frequencies of SN, VO, and OA than Sisak, and the total frequencies of SN and OA in both series are significantly higher in males. When, however, the series were analyzed by age and sex categories, the same trend was noted only in SN. The frequencies and severity of VO and OA could not be interpreted in keeping with the historic and contemporary ethnographic sources and were additionally, unlike SN, found to be strongly correlated with increased age. This study, therefore, suggests that while SN are useful indicators of different lifestyles and/or different activity patterns between various archaeological populations, VO and OA are-possibly because of their more varied etiologies-less useful markers of activity-related stress.
为了测试 Schmorl 结节(SN)、椎体骨赘(VO)和关节突关节炎(OA)在多大程度上是与活动相关的应激的有用指标,对来自克罗地亚的两个早期现代骨骼样本——Koprivno 和 Sisak 中的这些指标的频率和表达严重程度进行了分析。历史和当代民族志资料表明,Koprivno 的生活条件更为苛刻,而且这两个群体都存在劳动分工。共分析了 2552 个椎体(990 个来自 Koprivno,1562 个来自 Sisak)和 5186 个关节突(2135 个来自 Koprivno,3051 个来自 Sisak)。Koprivno 的 SN、VO 和 OA 的总频率明显高于 Sisak,并且两个系列中 SN 和 OA 的总频率在男性中明显更高。然而,当按年龄和性别类别对系列进行分析时,仅在 SN 中观察到相同的趋势。VO 和 OA 的频率和严重程度与历史和当代民族志资料不符,并且与年龄的增加呈强相关,这与 SN 不同。因此,这项研究表明,虽然 SN 是不同考古人群之间不同生活方式和/或不同活动模式的有用指标,但 VO 和 OA 是不太有用的与活动相关的应激的标志物,这可能是因为它们的病因更为多样化。