Phillips-Howard P A, West L J
Department of Epidemiology and Population Sciences, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
J R Soc Med. 1990 Feb;83(2):82-5. doi: 10.1177/014107689008300208.
All reports of adverse reactions with pyrimethamine-sulphadoxine (Fansidar), pyrimethamine-dapsone (Maloprim), and amodiaquine spontaneously reported through the UK national post-marketing system were reviewed. Retrospective reporting rates of serious reactions associated with these drugs were analysed using prescription data from the Department of Health, derived from the Prescription Pricing Authority, and relevant pharmaceutical companies. Whilst interpretation of these data requires caution, they allowed comparison with reporting rates from other studies. The reported rate for all serious reactions to pyrimethamine-sulphadoxine was 1:2100 prescriptions, and for cutaneous reactions was 1:4900 prescriptions, with a fatality rate of 1:11,100. The reported rate for serious reactions to pyrimethamine-dapsone was 1:9100 prescriptions, and for blood dyscrasias was 1:20,000 prescriptions, with a fatality rate of 1:75,000. The reported rate of blood dyscrasias associated with amodiaquine was 1:2100 users with a fatality rate of 1:31,000. Serious hepatic disorders occurred in 1:11 1000 pyrimethamine-sulphadoxine prescriptions, 1:75,200 pyrimethamine-dapsone prescriptions, and in 1:15,650 amodiaquine users. 35% of cases received these drugs needlessly as they were not exposed to drug resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum. Since few serious reactions have been reported to chloroquine plus proguanil, these data support guidelines which restrict the use of reviewed drugs for those at greatest risk of infection. Dosage data indicated that fatalities had taken higher doses and continued prophylaxis after onset of symptoms. Two thirds of serious reactions to the compound antimalarials were reported in females.
对通过英国国家上市后监测系统自发上报的所有有关乙胺嘧啶-磺胺多辛(Fansidar)、乙胺嘧啶-氨苯砜(Maloprim)和阿莫地喹的不良反应报告进行了审查。利用来自卫生部、处方定价管理局及相关制药公司的处方数据,分析了与这些药物相关的严重不良反应的回顾性报告率。虽然对这些数据的解读需谨慎,但它们可用于与其他研究的报告率进行比较。乙胺嘧啶-磺胺多辛所有严重不良反应的报告率为每2100张处方1例,皮肤反应的报告率为每4900张处方1例,死亡率为每11100张处方1例。乙胺嘧啶-氨苯砜严重不良反应的报告率为每9100张处方1例,血液系统疾病的报告率为每20000张处方1例,死亡率为每75000张处方1例。与阿莫地喹相关的血液系统疾病报告率为每2100名使用者1例,死亡率为每31000名使用者1例。严重肝脏疾病在乙胺嘧啶-磺胺多辛处方中发生率为每111000张处方1例,在乙胺嘧啶-氨苯砜处方中为每75200张处方1例,在阿莫地喹使用者中为每15650名使用者1例。35%使用这些药物的病例是不必要的,因为他们未接触到耐氯喹恶性疟原虫菌株。由于氯喹加氯胍的严重不良反应报告较少,这些数据支持了将所审查药物的使用限制于感染风险最高人群的指南。剂量数据表明,死亡病例服用了更高剂量药物且在症状出现后仍继续预防用药。复方抗疟药的严重不良反应有三分之二报告发生在女性身上。