Gregory Juliette, Bryan Karen
Leeds Youth Offending Service and NHS Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2011 Mar-Apr;46(2):202-15. doi: 10.3109/13682822.2010.490573.
Increasing numbers of children with behaviour and school problems (related to both academic achievement and social participation) are recognized as having undiagnosed speech, language and communication difficulties. Both speech, language and communication difficulties and school failure are risk factors for offending.
To investigate the prevalence of speech, language and communication difficulties in a group of persistent and prolific young offenders sentenced to the Intensive Supervision and Surveillance Programme (ISSP), and to provide a preliminary evaluation of the impact of speech and language therapy (SLT) intervention.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: Seventy-two entrants to ISSP over 12 months were screened by the speech and language therapist. Those showing difficulties then had a detailed language assessment followed by intervention delivered jointly by the speech and language therapist and the youth offending team staff. Reassessment occurred at programme completion.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: A total of 65% of those screened had profiles indicating that they had language difficulties and might benefit from speech and language therapy intervention. As a cohort, their language skills were lower than those of the general population, and 20% scored at the 'severely delayed' level on standardized assessment. This is the first study of speech and language therapy within community services for young offenders, and is the first to demonstrate language improvement detectable on standardized language tests. However, further research is needed to determine the precise role of speech and language therapy within the intervention programme.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: Children and young people with behavioural or school difficulties coming into contact with criminal justice, mental health, psychiatric, and social care services need to be systematically assessed for undiagnosed speech, language and communication difficulties. Appropriate interventions can then enable the young person to engage with verbally mediated interventions.
越来越多有行为和学校问题(与学业成绩和社会参与度相关)的儿童被认为存在未被诊断出的言语、语言和沟通障碍。言语、语言和沟通障碍以及学业失败都是犯罪的风险因素。
调查一群被判处强化监督和监管计划(ISSP)的惯犯和多产少年犯中言语、语言和沟通障碍的患病率,并对言语和语言治疗(SLT)干预的影响进行初步评估。
言语和语言治疗师对12个月内进入ISSP的72名人员进行了筛查。那些表现出困难的人随后进行了详细的语言评估,然后由言语和语言治疗师与青少年犯罪问题处理团队的工作人员共同进行干预。在计划完成时进行重新评估。
共有65%接受筛查的人员表现出有语言困难的特征,可能会从言语和语言治疗干预中受益。作为一个群体,他们的语言技能低于一般人群,20%的人在标准化评估中得分处于“严重延迟”水平。这是第一项针对社区服务中青少年犯罪者的言语和语言治疗的研究,也是第一项证明在标准化语言测试中可检测到语言改善的研究。然而,需要进一步的研究来确定言语和语言治疗在干预计划中的确切作用。
与刑事司法、心理健康、精神病学和社会护理服务接触的有行为或学校困难的儿童和青少年需要系统地评估是否存在未被诊断出的言语、语言和沟通障碍。适当的干预措施可以使年轻人参与到以言语为媒介的干预中。