Federal University of Bahia, Brazil.
Department of Pediatrics, Federal University of Bahia, Brazil.
Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2023 May-Aug;25(2):70-79. doi: 10.18176/resp.00070.
Good communication is essential for resolving social conflicts, especially in closed communities such as prisons. When communication is interrupted by factors such as hearing loss or difficulties in coordination, voice, language, fluency, or disruption of any of the biological systems required to communicate, Human Communication Disorders can appear. This review aimed to identify the most prevalent communication disorders amongst prison inmates.
Systematic review through databases of studies that analyze individual inmates with communication disorders over the last 38 years. After reading the titles and abstracts and applying the eligibility criteria, 25 articles were selected and included in the final review.
A sample of 2,188 individuals was evaluated, two studies were conducted with a female population only, while twelve studied exclusively males, and 11 articles had a mixed population. All the studies included evaluated language and communication disorders in general, with language impairment being more prevalent There are no English language studies evaluating language and communication disorders in incarcerated individuals from African countries, Latin America or Asia.
Inmates have a high prevalence of language and communication disorders, and thus end up being more vulnerable within the prison system. Speech therapists are important members of the legal workforce and improve the health, well-being and participation of people in contact with or at risk of contact with the judicial system through the prevention, early detection, assessment and treatment of communication disorders.
良好的沟通对于解决社会冲突至关重要,尤其是在监狱等封闭社区。当沟通因听力损失或协调困难等因素而中断时,可能会出现人类沟通障碍。本综述旨在确定监狱囚犯中最常见的沟通障碍。
通过分析过去 38 年来个体囚犯沟通障碍的研究数据库进行系统回顾。在阅读标题和摘要并应用合格标准后,选择了 25 篇文章并纳入最终综述。
评估了 2188 个人的样本,其中两项研究仅针对女性人群进行,12 项研究仅针对男性人群进行,11 篇文章的研究人群为混合人群。所有研究都评估了语言和沟通障碍,语言障碍更为普遍。没有评估来自非洲国家、拉丁美洲或亚洲的囚犯的语言和沟通障碍的英文研究。
囚犯中语言和沟通障碍的患病率很高,因此在监狱系统中更容易受到伤害。言语治疗师是法律工作团队的重要成员,通过预防、早期发现、评估和治疗沟通障碍,提高与司法系统接触或有接触风险的人的健康、福利和参与度。