Gallagher Katherine A, Ravin Reid A, Schweitzer Eugene, Stern Tina, Bartlett Stephen T
Department of Vascular Surgery, Columbia University Medical Center, New York Presbyterian Hospital, New York, NY, USA.
Ann Vasc Surg. 2011 May;25(4):448-53. doi: 10.1016/j.avsg.2010.12.007. Epub 2011 Mar 25.
Solid organ transplantation in elderly patients has become more common in recent years. An increasing number of patients present with renal failure requiring transplantation and comorbid occlusive or aneurysmal aortic pathology. The optimal strategy for the timing and management of the aortic disease and renal transplantation in these patients is unknown. Before the availability of endovascular therapies, our policy was to provide open repair of aortic disease before cadaveric transplantation, or by simultaneous aortic reconstruction with renal allotransplantation if a living donor was available. Since the wide acceptance of endovascular modalities, our strategy has changed to take advantage of endovascular treatment pre-transplant. This study examines the outcome of both approaches.
We performed a retrospective review of 12 patients between 1996 and 2009 who underwent both renal transplantation and a major abdominal aortic procedure either simultaneously (n = 6), metachronous, with the procedures occurring within the same month (n = 2), or distant, with the aortic procedures occurring between 5 and 24 months before or after transplantation (n = 4). All patients with occlusive disease underwent an aortobifemoral bypass, one before transplant, one subsequent to transplantation, and four simultaneous with a renal allograft. To assess renal transplant status, patients' serum creatinine levels were followed up every 3 months. Of the 12 patients, eight underwent open aortic procedures, whereas four underwent endovascular aortic aneurysm repair. Patients who underwent endovascular aortic aneurysm repair were followed up with ultrasound examinations at 6-month intervals, and with contrast computed tomography scans every other year.
Aortic reconstruction was performed successfully in all the 12 patients irrespective of timing strategy. All the patients who underwent endovascular repair had functional renal allografts for the duration of follow-up. Two patients had simultaneous aortobifemoral bypass and pancreas-kidney transplantation without complication. Among the patients with open aortic repairs, there was one 5-year mortality and one patient had failure of two renal allografts. None of the patients had limb loss, and aortic grafts (one limb required a secondary procedure) remained patent. The 5-year patient survival of 90% and kidney survival of 75% appeared similar to results in the general transplant population without aortic disease. Two significant complications related to the open procedures were observed: two renal transplants developed postoperative hematomas requiring evacuation and one aortobifemoral bypass (ABF) developed a femoral wound infection requiring evacuation and sartorius flap closure. The 30-day mortality rate in all patients was zero. The length of stay for patients receiving simultaneous procedures ranged from 5 to 14 days (median, 10.5) and was significantly lower than the 10-52-day (median, 18) combined length of stay in the metachronous and/or distant groups (p = 0.016).
The coexistence of aortic disease and renal transplantation is an increasingly common clinical scenario. Exclusion from transplantation of patients with major aortoiliac disease is commonplace in many transplant centers as early registry data suggested a poor outcome. Appropriate planning with a vascular surgical team can lead to outcomes, which are comparable with the general transplant population without significant aortic disease.
近年来,老年患者的实体器官移植变得越来越普遍。越来越多的患者因肾衰竭需要移植,同时合并有闭塞性或动脉瘤性主动脉病变。对于这些患者,主动脉疾病和肾移植的时机选择及管理的最佳策略尚不清楚。在血管内治疗出现之前,我们的策略是在尸体肾移植前对主动脉疾病进行开放修复,或者如果有活体供体,则在进行肾同种异体移植的同时进行主动脉重建。自从血管内治疗被广泛接受以来,我们的策略已转变为在移植前利用血管内治疗。本研究探讨了这两种方法的结果。
我们对1996年至2009年间12例患者进行了回顾性研究,这些患者同时接受了肾移植和主要的腹主动脉手术(n = 6)、同期手术(手术在同一个月内进行,n = 2)或分期手术(主动脉手术在移植前或移植后5至24个月进行,n = 4)。所有患有闭塞性疾病的患者均接受了主动脉双股动脉搭桥术,其中1例在移植前进行,1例在移植后进行,4例与肾同种异体移植同时进行。为了评估肾移植状态,每3个月对患者的血清肌酐水平进行随访。12例患者中,8例接受了主动脉开放手术,4例接受了血管内主动脉瘤修复术。接受血管内主动脉瘤修复术的患者每隔6个月进行超声检查,每隔一年进行对比计算机断层扫描。
无论采用何种时机策略,12例患者的主动脉重建均成功完成。所有接受血管内修复的患者在随访期间肾同种异体移植均功能良好。2例患者同时进行了主动脉双股动脉搭桥术和胰肾移植,无并发症发生。在接受主动脉开放修复的患者中,有1例患者5年死亡,1例患者的两个肾同种异体移植失败。所有患者均未出现肢体丧失,主动脉移植物(1例肢体需要二次手术)保持通畅。90%的患者5年生存率和75%的肾脏生存率与无主动脉疾病的一般移植人群的结果相似。观察到与开放手术相关的两个严重并发症:2例肾移植术后出现血肿需要引流,1例主动脉双股动脉搭桥术出现股部伤口感染需要引流并进行缝匠肌皮瓣闭合。所有患者的30天死亡率为零。接受同期手术的患者住院时间为5至14天(中位数为10.5天),明显低于同期和/或分期组10至52天(中位数为18天)的联合住院时间(p = 0.016)。
主动脉疾病和肾移植并存是一种越来越常见的临床情况。许多移植中心通常会将患有严重主髂动脉疾病的患者排除在移植之外,因为早期登记数据显示预后较差。与血管外科团队进行适当的规划可以取得与无严重主动脉疾病的一般移植人群相当的结果。