Lagier F, Cartier A, Malo J L
Service de Pneumologie-Allergologie, Hôpital Sainte-Marguerite, Marseille.
Rev Mal Respir. 1990;7(4):337-41.
The authors have carried out a statistical analysis of cases of occupational asthma and other occupational lung diseases submitted to the Ministry of Labour in Quebec between 1986 and 1988. The total number of claims was 913, 993, and 866 respectively for the 3 years of which 61% to 71% were accepted. 41% to 55% were new assessments. Of 228 new claims accepted in 1988, 81 (36%) were for occupational asthma. This number surpassed the number of claims accepted for traditional pneumoconiosis (asbestos = 30, and silicose = 36). Isocyanates were the principle cause of occupational asthma (23% of cases were recognised in 1988) followed by flour, red and white cedar, snow crab process workers, and various pharmaceutical products and grains. In comparison with statistics in 1977, one noticed there was a large reversal of the frequency of certain occupational lung diseases that are recognised, because at that time asbestosis and silicosis were the principle causes of claims put forward and accepted. The authors discuss the statistical bias of occupational lung disease obtained by medico-legal agencies. Although occupational asthma has not been the object of the systematic screening program in the work place and although there is a tendency for workers to avoid or abandon their occupation more often than in the traditional pneumoconioses current protection is sufficient in Quebec to motivate individuals who are possibly suffering from occupational asthma to put in a claim for compensation.
作者对1986年至1988年间提交给魁北克劳工部的职业性哮喘和其他职业性肺病病例进行了统计分析。这三年的索赔总数分别为913、993和866起,其中61%至71%被接受。41%至55%是新的评估。在1988年接受的228起新索赔中,81起(36%)是职业性哮喘。这个数字超过了传统尘肺病(石棉沉着病 = 30起,矽肺病 = 36起)的索赔接受数量。异氰酸酯是职业性哮喘的主要原因(1988年确认的病例中有23%),其次是面粉、红雪松和白雪松、雪蟹加工工人以及各种药品和谷物。与1977年的统计数据相比,人们注意到某些已确认的职业性肺病的发病频率发生了很大逆转,因为当时石棉沉着病和矽肺病是提出并被接受索赔的主要原因。作者讨论了法医学机构获得的职业性肺病统计偏差。尽管职业性哮喘并非工作场所系统筛查项目的对象,而且与传统尘肺病相比,工人更倾向于回避或放弃工作,但魁北克目前的保护措施足以促使可能患有职业性哮喘的个人提出赔偿索赔。