Department of Psychiatry, College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, 1051 Riverside Drive, New York City, NY 10032, USA.
Neurotoxicology. 2011 Aug;32(4):450-7. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2011.03.009. Epub 2011 Mar 29.
Recently, epidemiologic studies of developmental neurotoxicology have been challenged to increase focus on co-exposure to multiple toxicants. Earlier reports, including our own work in Bangladesh, have demonstrated independent associations between neurobehavioral function and exposure to both arsenic (As) and manganese (Mn) in school-aged children. Our earlier studies, however, were not designed to examine possible interactive effects of exposure to both As and Mn. To allow investigation of possible synergistic impact of simultaneous exposures, we recruited a new sample of 299 8-11 year old children, stratified by design on As (above and below 10 μg/L) and Mn (above and below 500 μg/L) concentrations of household wells. When adjusted only for each other, both As and Mn in whole blood (BAs; BMn) were significantly negatively related to most WISC-IV subscale scores. With further adjustment for socio-demographic features and ferritin, BMn remained significantly associated with reduced Perceptual Reasoning and Working Memory scores; associations for BAs, and for other subscales, were expectably negative, significantly for Verbal Comprehension. Urinary As (per gram creatinine) was significantly negatively associated with Verbal Comprehension scores, even with adjustment for BMn and other contributors. Mn by As interactions were not significant in adjusted or unadjusted models (all p's>0.25). Findings are consistent with other reports documenting adverse impact of both As and Mn exposure on child developmental outcomes, although associations appear muted at these relatively low exposure levels.
最近,发育神经毒理学的流行病学研究受到挑战,需要更加关注多种毒物的共同暴露。早期的报告,包括我们在孟加拉国的工作,已经证明了神经行为功能与学龄儿童接触砷(As)和锰(Mn)之间存在独立的关联。然而,我们之前的研究并不是为了研究接触 As 和 Mn 之间可能存在的交互作用。为了研究同时暴露可能产生的协同影响,我们招募了 299 名 8-11 岁的儿童作为新的样本,根据家庭水井中 As(高于和低于 10μg/L)和 Mn(高于和低于 500μg/L)的浓度进行分层设计。当仅对彼此进行调整时,全血中的 As 和 Mn(BAs;BMn)与大多数 WISC-IV 分量表得分呈显著负相关。进一步调整社会人口特征和铁蛋白后,BMn 与感知推理和工作记忆得分降低仍然显著相关;BAs 和其他分量表的关联是预期的负相关,对言语理解的影响最为显著。尿中 As(每克肌酐)与言语理解得分呈显著负相关,即使调整了 BMn 和其他因素也是如此。在调整或未调整的模型中,Mn 与 As 的相互作用均不显著(所有 p 值均>0.25)。这些发现与其他报告一致,这些报告记录了接触 As 和 Mn 对儿童发育结果的不利影响,尽管在这些相对较低的暴露水平下,关联似乎较为缓和。