Salvat-Plana M, Abilleira S, Jiménez C, Marta J, Gallofré M
Pla Director Malaltia Vascular Cerebral, Agència d'Informació, Avaluació i Qualitat en Salut (AIAQS), Barcelona, España.
Rev Calid Asist. 2011 May-Jun;26(3):174-83. doi: 10.1016/j.cali.2010.12.004. Epub 2011 Mar 31.
To define a core set of evidence-based performance indicators (PIs) for the assessment of in-hospital stroke care quality by means of consensus prioritization by a panel of experts representing stroke care professionals in three Autonomous Communities (Catalonia, Aragon and Balearic Islands).
We used a modified Delphi method in two rounds to prioritize a set of PIs from among 70 indicators identified by a review of the literature and those already used in previous experiences. Consensus on validity was reached when ≥ 75% of panellists rated a PI in the top tertile, using a 1-9 Likert scale. On the basis of the percentage distribution of annual stroke admissions in each one of the 3 regions, we configured a multidisciplinary panel of 56 experts involved in the hospital care of acute stroke patients.
Twenty-nine out of the 70 PIs initially put forward to the panel, have been prioritized after 2 rounds. The eventual core set of PIs consists of those with the highest scores and represent all areas of hospital-based stroke care. A subgroup of 5 PIs is applicable to Primary Stroke Centres only. The 3 highest rated PIs, which achieved the greatest consensus among the experts, are anticoagulants for AF, antithrombotics at discharge and continued physiotherapy planned at discharge.
Through a Delphi method, we have obtained a core set of evidence-based PIs considered of high importance and agreed by a multidisciplinary panel of stroke care experts from the participating Communities, which represent over 20% of the Spanish population.
通过由代表三个自治区(加泰罗尼亚、阿拉贡和巴利阿里群岛)中风护理专业人员的专家小组进行共识优先级排序,确定一套基于证据的核心绩效指标(PI),用于评估医院内中风护理质量。
我们采用两轮改良德尔菲法,从文献综述确定的70项指标以及先前经验中已使用的指标中,对一组PI进行优先级排序。当≥75%的小组成员使用1 - 9李克特量表将一个PI评为前三分位数时,达成有效性共识。根据三个地区中每个地区年度中风入院人数的百分比分布,我们组建了一个由56名参与急性中风患者医院护理的专家组成的多学科小组。
最初提交给小组的70项PI中,有29项在两轮后被确定为优先级指标。最终的核心PI集由得分最高的指标组成,代表了医院中风护理的所有领域。一个由5项PI组成的子组仅适用于初级中风中心。专家们达成最大共识的3项评分最高的PI分别是房颤的抗凝治疗、出院时的抗血栓治疗以及出院时计划的持续物理治疗。
通过德尔菲法,我们获得了一组基于证据的核心PI,这些PI被认为非常重要,并得到了来自参与社区的中风护理专家多学科小组的认可,这些社区占西班牙人口的20%以上。