Office of Medical Education, Sydney Medical School, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Med Educ. 2011 May;45(5):497-503. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2010.03887.x.
Despite a recognised need for richer narratives about academic medicine, much of the literature is limited to an analysis of the enablers and barriers associated with recruitment and retention, and focuses on analysing the development of research career pathways. We explored academic clinician-educators' experiences of entering into and navigating academic medicine, with a particular focus on those who privilege teaching above research.
Data were collected through interviews and focus groups conducted across a medical school at one Australian university. We used socio-cognitive career theory to provide theoretical insight into the factors that influence academic clinician-educators' interests, choice and motivations regarding entering and pursuing a teaching pathway within academic medicine. Framework analysis was used to illustrate key themes in the data.
We identified a number of themes related to academic clinician-educators' engagement and performance within an academic medicine career focused on teaching. These include contextual factors associated with how academic medicine is structured as a discipline, cultural perceptions regarding what constitutes legitimate practice in academia, experiential factors associated with the opportunity to develop a professional identity commensurate with being an educator, and socialisation practices.
The emphasis on research in academia can engender feelings of marginalisation and lack of credibility for those clinicians who favour teaching over research. The prevailing focus on supporting and socialising clinicians in research will need to change substantially to facilitate the rise of the academic clinician-educator.
尽管人们认识到需要更丰富的学术医学叙事,但许多文献仅限于分析与招聘和留任相关的促进因素和障碍,并侧重于分析研究职业道路的发展。我们探讨了学术临床医生教育家进入和驾驭学术医学的经验,特别关注那些重视教学甚于研究的人。
数据通过在澳大利亚一所大学的医学院进行的访谈和焦点小组收集。我们使用社会认知职业理论为影响学术临床医生教育家进入和追求学术医学教学途径的兴趣、选择和动机的因素提供理论见解。采用框架分析来说明数据中的主要主题。
我们确定了一些与专注于教学的学术医学职业中临床医生教育家的参与和表现相关的主题。这些主题包括与学术医学作为一门学科的结构相关的背景因素、与学术界合法实践相关的文化观念、与发展与教育者身份相称的专业身份的机会相关的经验因素,以及社会化实践。
学术界对研究的重视可能会使那些重视教学甚于研究的临床医生感到边缘化和缺乏信誉。为了促进学术临床医生教育家的崛起,需要从根本上改变对支持和社会化临床医生从事研究的关注。