Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College, Arizona State University Tempe, AZ 85287, USA.
J Atten Disord. 2012 Oct;16(7):562-71. doi: 10.1177/1087054711403713. Epub 2011 Apr 13.
OJECTIVE: The Kulhavy model for text learning using organized spatial displays proposes that learning will be increased when participants view visual images prior to related text. In contrast to previous studies, this study also included students who exhibited symptoms of ADHD.
Participants were presented with either a map-text or text-map condition.
The map-text condition led to a significantly higher performance than the text-map condition, overall. However, students who endorsed more symptoms of inattention and hyperactivity-impulsivity scored more poorly when asked to recall text facts, text features, and map features and were less able to correctly place map features on a reconstructed map than were students who endorsed fewer symptoms.
The results of the study support the Kulhavy model for typical students; however, the benefit of viewing a display prior to text was not seen for students with ADHD symptoms, thus supporting previous studies that have demonstrated that ADHD appears to negatively affect operations that occur in working memory.
目的:Kulhavy 模型使用有组织的空间显示来进行文本学习,提出当参与者在相关文本之前查看视觉图像时,学习效果将会增强。与之前的研究不同,本研究还包括表现出 ADHD 症状的学生。方法:参与者呈现地图-文本或文本-地图条件。结果:总体而言,地图-文本条件导致的表现明显优于文本-地图条件。然而,当被要求回忆文本事实、文本特征和地图特征,以及将地图特征正确放置在重建地图上时,表现出更多注意力不集中和多动冲动症状的学生得分较低,并且比表现出较少症状的学生更难以正确放置地图特征。结论:该研究的结果支持典型学生的 Kulhavy 模型;然而,对于有 ADHD 症状的学生,在阅读文本之前查看显示并没有带来益处,这支持了之前的研究,即 ADHD 似乎会对工作记忆中发生的操作产生负面影响。