Institute for Hygiene and Medical Ecology, School of Medicine, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia.
Environ Int. 2011 Jul;37(5):1030-41. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2011.03.017. Epub 2011 Apr 14.
The goal of this review was to investigate methodological differences in studies on the effects of aircraft or road-traffic noise on blood pressure (BP) of urban children, emphasizing the similarities and differences in blood pressure measurements.
A literature search has identified eight peer-reviewed studies, four conference proceedings and one PhD thesis on the effects of aircraft or road-traffic noise on children's blood pressure published in English in the last 30 years. Most of the studies were cross-sectional, and four studies were longitudinal, with follow-up period from one to three years. The studies were analyzed according to the following methodological issues: study design, children's characteristics, noise exposure assessment and blood pressure measurements. The effects of noise on systolic and diastolic pressure were presented in detail.
Studies on aircraft noise had more uniform methodology, indicating a slight tendency towards a positive relationship between aircraft noise exposure and BP in children. The studies on road-traffic noise were methodologically diverse, but compared to aircraft noise studies they showed a more uniform trend in the direction of a positive relationship with systolic BP. The time, place and number of BP measurements, as well as the devices and cuff sizes varied among the studies. Children's age, gender, body composition and ethnicity, and socio-economic status remain the greatest source of diversity in BP values.
The reviewed studies were methodologically diverse concerning noise exposure assessment, BP measurement, study design and control for confounders. In spite of this, they indicate a tendency toward positive association between noise exposure and children's blood pressure. We recommended strategies that might help researchers adopt similar procedures when measuring BP in future field studies.
本综述旨在调查关于飞机或道路交通噪声对城市儿童血压(BP)影响的研究方法差异,重点关注血压测量方面的异同。
通过文献检索,确定了过去 30 年中以英文发表的 8 项关于飞机或道路交通噪声对儿童血压影响的同行评审研究、4 项会议记录和 1 项博士论文。大多数研究为横断面研究,4 项研究为纵向研究,随访时间为 1 至 3 年。根据以下方法问题对研究进行分析:研究设计、儿童特征、噪声暴露评估和血压测量。详细介绍了噪声对收缩压和舒张压的影响。
飞机噪声研究的方法更为统一,表明飞机噪声暴露与儿童 BP 之间存在轻微的正相关趋势。道路交通噪声研究在方法学上存在差异,但与飞机噪声研究相比,它们显示出与收缩压呈正相关的更一致趋势。研究中血压测量的时间、地点和次数,以及设备和袖带尺寸各不相同。儿童的年龄、性别、身体成分和种族以及社会经济地位仍然是 BP 值差异的最大来源。
综述研究在噪声暴露评估、BP 测量、研究设计和混杂因素控制方面存在方法学差异。尽管如此,它们表明噪声暴露与儿童血压之间存在正相关趋势。我们建议了一些策略,可能有助于研究人员在未来的现场研究中采用类似的程序来测量 BP。