Faraldo-García Ana, Santos-Pérez Sofía, Labella-Caballero Torcuato, Soto-Varela Andrés
Servicio de Otorrinolaringología, Complejo Hospitalario Universitario Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, España.
Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2011 Sep-Oct;62(5):333-8. doi: 10.1016/j.otorri.2011.03.003. Epub 2011 Apr 30.
The sensory organization test and the limits of stability are the gold standard for dynamic posturography. It is postulated that these measurements vary depending on age, activity of the subject and musculoskeletal system, emotional condition or other factors. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of gender on the above-mentioned analyses.
70 healthy subjects (35 males and 35 females); mean age: 44.9 years. A clinical history was taken and a physical and otoneurological exploration was performed for each subject, along with a posturography study using the Neurocom SMART Balance Master platform model. The statistical study was carried out with the ANOVA test (p<0.05).
Condition 5 presented the lowest percentage of balance in both sexes (64.36%). The highest percentage of balance in males was in Condition 1 (p<0.001) and the lowest in 3 (p=0.030). There were no differences in the sensory analysis. The lowest employment of ankle strategy was in Condition 5 for both sexes (88.61%); women used the ankle strategy in Condition 4 more efficiently (p=0.0129). There were also differences in the time of reaction towards the right (p=0.022) and the mean (p=0.011) (higher in females), and in the speed of movement backwards (p=0.001) and towards the right (p=0.04) (higher in males). In path length and directional control, there were no differences.
Gender differences should be taken into consideration for vestibular rehabilitation. Greater speed in conducting the tests does not lead to better balance control.
感觉组织测试和稳定极限测试是动态姿势描记法的金标准。据推测,这些测量结果会因年龄、受试者的活动情况和肌肉骨骼系统、情绪状况或其他因素而有所不同。本研究的目的是确定性别对上述分析的影响。
70名健康受试者(35名男性和35名女性);平均年龄:44.9岁。对每位受试者进行临床病史采集、体格检查和耳神经学检查,并使用Neurocom SMART Balance Master平台模型进行姿势描记研究。采用方差分析进行统计学研究(p<0.05)。
在两种性别中,条件5的平衡百分比最低(64.36%)。男性平衡百分比最高的是条件1(p<0.001),最低的是条件3(p=0.030)。感觉分析方面没有差异。两种性别在条件5下踝关节策略的使用率最低(88.61%);女性在条件4下更有效地使用了踝关节策略(p=0.0129)。在对右侧的反应时间(p=0.022)和平均值(p=0.011)(女性更高),以及向后(p=0.001)和向右(p=0.04)的移动速度(男性更高)方面也存在差异。在路径长度和方向控制方面没有差异。
前庭康复应考虑性别差异。更快的测试速度并不会带来更好的平衡控制。