Yale University School of Public Health, New Haven, CT 06520-8034, USA.
Int J Qual Health Care. 2011 Jun;23(3):258-68. doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzr019. Epub 2011 Apr 30.
The aim of this study was to develop and to assess the validity and reliability of two brief questionnaires for assessing patient experiences with hospital and outpatient care in a low-income setting.
Using literature review and data from focus groups (n = 14), we developed questionnaires to assess patient experiences with inpatient (I-PAHC) and with outpatient (O-PAHC) care in a low-income setting. Questionnaires were administered in person by trained interviewers. Construct validity was assessed with factor analysis; convergent validity was assessed by correlating summary scores for each scale with overall patient evaluations, and reliability was assessed with Cronbach's alpha coefficients.
Eight health facilities in Ethiopia.
Patients >18 years old who had a hospital stay >1 day (n = 230), and patients who received outpatient care (n = 486).
Patient evaluations of health care experiences.
The factor analysis revealed 12 items that loaded on five factors for the I-PAHC questionnaire. The O-PAHC showed similar results with 13 items that loaded on four factors. Summary scores for nearly all factors were significantly associated (P-value < 0.05) with the patient's overall evaluation score. The measure of reliability, Cronbach's alpha coefficients, showed good to excellent internal consistency for all scales.
The I-PAHC on O-PAHC questionnaires can be useful in assessing patients' evaluations of care delivery in low-income settings. The questionnaires are brief and can be integrated into health systems strengthening efforts with the support of leadership at the health facility and the country levels.
本研究旨在开发并评估两份简短问卷在评估低收入环境下患者对医院和门诊护理体验的有效性和可靠性。
通过文献回顾和焦点小组(n=14)的数据,我们开发了评估低收入环境下患者住院(I-PAHC)和门诊(O-PAHC)护理体验的问卷。问卷由经过培训的访谈者亲自管理。结构有效性通过因子分析进行评估;通过将每个量表的综合评分与患者整体评价进行相关性分析来评估收敛有效性;通过 Cronbach's alpha 系数评估可靠性。
埃塞俄比亚的 8 家卫生机构。
住院时间超过 1 天的>18 岁患者(n=230)和接受门诊护理的患者(n=486)。
患者对医疗保健体验的评价。
因子分析显示,I-PAHC 问卷的 12 项指标加载到 5 个因子上。O-PAHC 也有类似的结果,13 项指标加载到 4 个因子上。几乎所有因子的综合评分都与患者的整体评价得分显著相关(P 值<0.05)。可靠性测量,Cronbach's alpha 系数,显示所有量表的内部一致性良好到优秀。
I-PAHC 和 O-PAHC 问卷可用于评估低收入环境下患者对护理提供的评价。这些问卷简洁,可以在卫生设施和国家层面的领导层的支持下,纳入卫生系统强化工作中。