Alberti Hugh, Alberti Benjamin
School of Medicine & Health, Durham University, Queens Campus, Stockton, United Kingdom.
Pan Afr Med J. 2009 Aug 22;3:2.
Gender differences in access to high quality care for chronic illnesses have been suggested yet little work in this potentially vital area of health care inequality has been undertaken in Africa. We explored the influence of patient gender on the care of people with diabetes within a multi-method, national study of diabetes management in primary care in Tunisia.
Methodologies used were quantitative (nationwide randomized study of 2160 medical records) and qualitative (participant observation, focus groups and interviews of patients and health care professionals).
Differences in patient characteristics, treatments prescribed, process and outcome data and access to care variables were demonstrated. The most striking disparity found was the high female to male ratio of patients attending for diabetes care (61.1%). A number of possible explanations for this emerged: Men were thought to under-attend for practical, financial and behavioural reasons whereas women were thought to have increased morbidity and potentially over-attend for social and psychological reasons.
We have demonstrated a number of disparities in the care of men and women with diabetes in Tunisian primary care. In particular, a dual but related problem emerges from the data: more women than men attend for diabetes care and yet women do not get the same level of risk factor control as men. A number of local explanations for these disparities have emerged, which inform our analysis of the impact of gendered beliefs on diabetes care. Strategies to address these disparities will require a careful consideration of local beliefs and practices.
有研究表明,在获得慢性病高质量护理方面存在性别差异,但在非洲这个医疗保健不平等的潜在重要领域,相关研究甚少。我们在突尼斯初级保健糖尿病管理的一项多方法全国性研究中,探讨了患者性别对糖尿病患者护理的影响。
采用的方法包括定量研究(对2160份病历进行全国范围的随机研究)和定性研究(参与观察、焦点小组以及对患者和医护人员的访谈)。
在患者特征、所开处方治疗、过程和结果数据以及获得护理变量方面均显示出差异。最显著的差异是前来接受糖尿病护理的患者中女性与男性的比例很高(61.1%)。对此出现了一些可能的解释:男性因实际、经济和行为原因就诊率较低,而女性则因发病率增加以及社会和心理原因就诊率可能较高。
我们已经证明突尼斯初级保健中糖尿病男性和女性患者在护理方面存在一些差异。特别是,数据中出现了一个双重但相关的问题:接受糖尿病护理的女性多于男性,但女性并未获得与男性相同水平的危险因素控制。针对这些差异出现了一些当地的解释,这为我们分析性别观念对糖尿病护理的影响提供了依据。解决这些差异的策略将需要仔细考虑当地的观念和做法。