Clonal variation in gene methylation: c-H-ras and alpha-hCG regions vary independently in human fibroblast lineages.

The stability of DNA methylation has been followed in clonal lineages of human diploid fibroblasts, for the gene regions encoding the c-H-ras proto-oncogene and the alpha subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin (alpha-hCG). Although methylation losses predominated, both de novo gains and losses of cytosine methylation were observed in subclones and sub-subclones, at frequencies which differed between individual clonal lineages, and between the 2 gene regions compared. Methylation of these loci varied independently among clones; e.g., a lineage which showed frequent methylation loss in the c-H-ras gene region remained highly methylated for alpha-hCG, and vice versa. Thus, the fidelity with which DNA methylation is inherited in specific endogenous gene regions must be governed by a clone-specific property affecting local chromatin structure, but apparently not by gene expression per se. Late in the replicative life-span of diploid fibroblasts, as cell replication slowed, restriction patterns for methylation-sensitive enzymes became simpler and more discrete, while those for other enzymes did not change. This is interpreted as a consequence of 'clonal succession', in which the fastest-replicating or longest-lived clones/subclones eventually predominate in a cell population; it could also reflect a decreased rate or a non-random selection of methylation changes in late-passage cells.