Department of Physics, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina 27858, USA.
Int J Radiat Biol. 2012 Jan;88(1-2):2-9. doi: 10.3109/09553002.2011.574781. Epub 2011 May 19.
Although great progress has been made, numerous challenges remain in the development of Monte Carlo (MC) charged-particle track structure simulation models. Such models have evolved from the simple gas phase target models to those using condensed phase interaction data coupled with complex targets representing cellular and molecular constituents of mammalian tissue. A wide choice of MC models is now available ranging from those based on the physics of continuous slowing down, to simulations following each interaction on an event-by-event basis. The choice of code depends largely on requirements for computational speed, and the degree of detail required; however, one must be continuously vigilant to recognise the inherent limitations of the model chosen.
There remain numerous questions of the accuracy and completeness of the interaction physics that present challenges to MC modellers. Recent evidence suggests that the yields of electrons with energies less than a few hundred eV might be substantially overestimated by the elastic and inelastic cross-sections used in many codes. Densely ionising heavy ions present modelling challenges when the rate of energy loss is sufficient to ionise essentially 'every' atom along the ion path. Effects of electron capture and loss by moving heavy ions present significant challenges for modellers particularly for accurate simulation for ions heavier than protons and helium ions? The average effective-charge provides an inadequate description for estimating differential cross-sections for energy loss. These and other questions are considered.
尽管已经取得了巨大的进展,但在蒙特卡罗(MC)带电粒子径迹结构模拟模型的开发中仍然存在许多挑战。这些模型已经从简单的气相靶模型发展到使用凝聚相相互作用数据并结合代表哺乳动物组织细胞和分子成分的复杂靶的模型。现在有多种 MC 模型可供选择,范围从基于连续慢化物理的模型到逐个事件模拟相互作用的模型。代码的选择在很大程度上取决于对计算速度和所需详细程度的要求;但是,必须不断警惕所选模型的固有局限性。
目前,仍有许多关于相互作用物理的准确性和完整性的问题,这对 MC 建模者提出了挑战。最近的证据表明,许多代码中使用的弹性和非弹性截面可能会大大高估能量小于几百电子伏特的电子的产额。当能量损失速率足以使沿离子路径的几乎“每个”原子电离时,重离子的密集电离会带来建模挑战。移动重离子的电子俘获和损失的影响对建模者提出了重大挑战,特别是对于比质子和氦离子重的离子的准确模拟而言?平均有效电荷不足以描述能量损失微分截面的估算。这些和其他问题都在考虑之中。