Miron-Shatz Talya, Golan Ofra, Brezis Mayer, Siegal Gil, Doniger Glen M
Center for Medical Decision Making, Ono Academic College, Kiryat Ono, Israel.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2011;105(4):271-6. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2011.04.006. Epub 2011 Apr 29.
WHAT ABOUT POLICY REGARDING SDM? Though informed consent and patients' right to information are regulated by Israeli law, there is a low level of formal activities focused on shared decision making (SDM) in Israel. Further, there are few organized programs to promote SDM among medical professionals or the public, and governmental support of SDM-related research is minimal. WHAT ABOUT TOOLS - DECISION SUPPORT FOR PATIENTS? The Israeli government does not have a program on development of patient decision aids. WHAT ABOUT PROFESSIONAL INTEREST AND IMPLEMENTATION? Nonetheless, patients have begun to influence litigation in both formal and informal capacities, medical schools have begun to incorporate courses for improving physician-patient communication into their curricula, and the largest national health plan has initiated a plan to increase pubic awareness. Funding for researching and promoting SDM is not centrally allocated, and studies show that despite the positive effects of SDM, such an approach is infrequently applied in actual clinical practice, and initiatives to promote SDM (e.g., decision aids) are in their infancy. WHAT DOES THE FUTURE LOOK LIKE? In conclusion, though not actively promoting SDM at present, Israel, with its governmentally regulated universal coverage with good access to high-level services possesses all the requisite elements for rapid, widespread advances in SDM in future years.
关于共享决策(SDM)的政策是怎样的?尽管以色列法律对知情同意和患者的信息权有所规定,但以色列针对共享决策的正式活动水平较低。此外,在医疗专业人员或公众中,很少有有组织的项目来促进共享决策,政府对与共享决策相关研究的支持也微乎其微。关于工具——患者决策支持是怎样的?以色列政府没有关于开发患者决策辅助工具的项目。关于专业兴趣和实施情况如何?尽管如此,患者已经开始以正式和非正式的身份影响诉讼,医学院校已开始将改善医患沟通的课程纳入其课程体系,最大的国家卫生计划也已启动一项提高公众意识的计划。用于研究和推广共享决策的资金没有集中分配,研究表明,尽管共享决策有积极效果,但这种方法在实际临床实践中很少应用,促进共享决策的举措(如决策辅助工具)尚处于起步阶段。未来会怎样?总之,尽管以色列目前没有积极推广共享决策,但由于其政府监管的全民医保且能很好地获得高水平服务,具备了在未来几年实现共享决策快速、广泛发展的所有必要要素。