Department of Botany, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706 USA.
Am J Bot. 2002 Nov;89(11):1826-42. doi: 10.3732/ajb.89.11.1826.
Capparaceae and Brassicaceae have long been known to be closely related families, with the monophyly of Capparaceae more recently questioned. To elucidate the relationship between Brassicaceae and Capparaceae as well as to address infrafamilial relationships within Capparaceae, we analyzed sequence variation for a large sampling, especially of Capparaceae, of these two families using two chloroplast regions, trnL-trnF and ndhF. Results of parsimony and likelihood analyses strongly support the monophyly of Brassicaceae plus Capparaceae, excluding Forchhammeria, which is clearly placed outside the Brassicaceae and Capparaceae clade and suggest the recognition of three primary clades-Capparaceae subfamily (subf.) Capparoideae, subf. Cleomoideae, and Brassicaceae. Capparaceae monophyly is strongly contradicted with Cleomoideae appearing as sister to Brassicaceae. Two traditionally recognized subfamilies of Capparaceae, Dipterygioideae and Podandrogynoideae, are embedded within Cleomoideae. Whereas habit and some fruit characteristics demarcate the three major clades, floral symmetry, stamen number, leaf type, and fruit type all show homoplasy. Clades within Capparoideae show a biogeographical pattern based on this sampling. These results are consistent with several alternative classification schemes.
白花菜科和十字花科一直被认为是密切相关的科,白花菜科的单系性最近受到质疑。为了阐明十字花科和白花菜科之间的关系以及解决白花菜科内部的亚科关系,我们使用两个叶绿体区域 trnL-trnF 和 ndhF 对这两个科的大量样本进行了序列变异分析,特别是对白花菜科的样本进行了分析。简约和似然分析的结果强烈支持了十字花科加白花菜科的单系性,排除了 Forchhammeria,它明显位于十字花科和白花菜科分支之外,并表明需要识别三个主要分支——白花菜科亚科(亚科)Capparoideae、亚科 Cleomoideae 和十字花科。白花菜科的单系性强烈与 Cleomoideae 作为十字花科的姐妹群相矛盾。白花菜科的两个传统亚科,Dipterygioideae 和 Podandrogynoideae,都嵌入在 Cleomoideae 中。虽然习性和一些果实特征划定了三个主要分支,但花对称性、雄蕊数、叶型和果实类型都显示出趋同现象。Capparoideae 内的分支显示出基于这种采样的生物地理模式。这些结果与几种替代分类方案一致。