Cislak A, Safron M, Pratt M, Gaspar T, Luszczynska A
Warsaw School of Social Sciences and Humanities, Warsaw, Poland.
Child Care Health Dev. 2012 May;38(3):321-31. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2214.2011.01285.x. Epub 2011 Jul 13.
This umbrella review analysed the relationships between family variables and child/adolescent body weight, diet and physical activity. In line with theories of health behaviour change, it was assumed that behaviour-specific family variables (i.e. beliefs, perceptions and practices referring to food intake or physical activity) would have stronger support than more general family variables (i.e. socio-economic status or general parental practices). Data obtained from 18 systematic reviews (examining 375 quantitative studies) were analysed. Reviews of experimental trials generally supported the effectiveness of reward/positive reinforcement parental strategies, parental involvement in treatment or prevention programmes, and cognitive-behavioural treatment in reducing child/adolescent body mass and/or obesity. Results across reviews of correlational studies indicated that healthy nutrition of children/adolescents was related to only one parental practice (parental monitoring), but was associated with several behaviour-specific family variables (e.g. a lack of restrictive control over food choices, high intake of healthy foods and low intake of unhealthy foods by parents and siblings, low pressure to consume foods). With regard to adolescent physical activity, stronger support was also found for behaviour-specific variables (e.g. physical activity of siblings), and for certain socio-economic variables (e.g. parental education). Child and adolescent obesity prevention programmes should account for behaviour-specific family variables.
本伞状综述分析了家庭变量与儿童/青少年体重、饮食和身体活动之间的关系。根据健康行为改变理论,研究假设特定行为的家庭变量(即与食物摄入或身体活动相关的信念、认知和行为)比更一般的家庭变量(如社会经济地位或一般父母行为)能得到更强有力的支持。对从18项系统综述(涵盖375项定量研究)中获取的数据进行了分析。对实验性试验的综述总体上支持奖励/积极强化父母策略、父母参与治疗或预防计划以及认知行为治疗在降低儿童/青少年体重和/或肥胖方面的有效性。相关性研究综述的结果表明,儿童/青少年的健康营养仅与一种父母行为(父母监督)有关,但与几个特定行为的家庭变量相关(例如,对食物选择缺乏限制性控制、父母和兄弟姐妹对健康食物的高摄入量和对不健康食物的低摄入量、进食压力小)。关于青少年身体活动,特定行为变量(如兄弟姐妹的身体活动)和某些社会经济变量(如父母教育程度)也得到了更强有力的支持。儿童和青少年肥胖预防计划应考虑特定行为的家庭变量。