Department of Oral Health Promotion, Graduate School of Medical and Dental Sciences, Tokyo Medical and Dental University, Tokyo, Japan.
J Periodontal Res. 2011 Dec;46(6):722-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0765.2011.01395.x. Epub 2011 Jul 18.
Only a few clinical research studies have assessed different therapeutic approaches to oral malodor in subjects affected by periodontal diseases. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of periodontal treatment and tongue cleaning on oral malodor parameters in periodontitis and gingivitis patients.
The subjects were 102 periodontitis and 116 gingivitis patients with oral malodor. Oral malodor was measured by organoleptic test and Oral Chroma™. Oral health status, including tooth conditions, periodontal health, tongue coating and proteolytic activity of the BANA test in tongue coating were assessed. Subjects in each periodontal disease group were randomly assigned into two subgroups depending on the sequence of treatment: periodontal treatment and tongue cleaning. Oral malodor and oral health parameters were compared by groups and sequence of treatment.
For subjects in the periodontitis group, there were statistically significant reductions in oral malodor after periodontitis treatment or tongue cleaning; however, major reductions were found after periodontitis treatment. For those in the gingivitis group, there were also statistically significant reductions in oral malodor after gingivitis treatment or tongue cleaning, but the most marked reductions were observed after tongue cleaning. At the completion of treatment, all oral malodor parameters fell below the threshold levels in all subgroups.
The present study indicated that periodontal treatment played an important role and tongue cleaning contributed to a lesser extent to reduction in oral malodor in periodontitis patients. In contrast, tongue cleaning alone can be the primary approach to reduce oral malodor in gingivitis patients.
仅有少数临床研究评估了不同治疗方法对牙周病患者口腔异味的影响。本研究旨在评估牙周治疗和舌清洁对牙周炎和牙龈炎患者口腔异味参数的影响。
本研究共纳入 102 例牙周炎患者和 116 例牙龈炎患者,所有患者均存在口腔异味。通过感官测试和 Oral Chroma™ 评估口腔异味。评估口腔健康状况,包括牙齿状况、牙周健康、舌背涂层和舌背涂层 BANA 试验的蛋白水解活性。根据治疗顺序,将每个牙周病组的患者随机分为两组:牙周治疗和舌清洁。比较各组和治疗顺序对口腔异味和口腔健康参数的影响。
对于牙周炎组患者,牙周治疗或舌清洁后口腔异味明显降低;但牙周治疗后降低更为显著。对于牙龈炎组患者,牙龈炎治疗或舌清洁后口腔异味也明显降低,但舌清洁后降低更为显著。治疗结束时,所有亚组的所有口腔异味参数均降至阈值以下。
本研究表明,牙周治疗对牙周炎患者口腔异味的降低作用更为重要,而舌清洁的作用相对较小。相反,单独的舌清洁就可以作为降低牙龈炎患者口腔异味的主要方法。