School of Psychology, University of Newcastle, Ourimbah, Australia.
Psychiatry Res. 2011 Sep 30;193(3):177-81. doi: 10.1016/j.pscychresns.2011.03.002. Epub 2011 Jul 18.
The N2 and P3 components of the event-related potential (ERP) are putative markers of inhibition in the Go/NoGo task. If this is the case, they should be unaffected by stimulus presentation modality. Theoretical researchers have suggested that the effect is smaller or absent with auditory stimuli, while others have shown that the effect depends on the perceptual similarity of the stimuli. Meanwhile, clinical researchers appear to be unaware of the debate. This study examined the N2 and P3 NoGo effects elicited by five sets of auditory stimuli varying in perceptual similarity. The N2 NoGo effect was significant for similar and different letters, and for similar tones, but not for different tones or novel sounds. As expected by the perceptual overlap hypothesis, the largest N2 NoGo effect was observed with the similar letters. In contrast, the P3 NoGo effect was significant and of a similar magnitude for all stimulus sets. The differential effect of the stimulus sets suggests separable underlying processes reflected in N2 and P3. Guidelines are provided for clinical researchers wishing to use auditory stimuli in the Go/NoGo task.
事件相关电位(ERP)的 N2 和 P3 成分是 Go/NoGo 任务中抑制作用的假定标志物。如果是这样,它们不应受到刺激呈现方式的影响。理论研究人员认为,听觉刺激的效果较小或不存在,而其他人则表明,效果取决于刺激的感知相似性。与此同时,临床研究人员似乎没有意识到这场争论。本研究通过五种不同感知相似性的听觉刺激来检查 N2 和 P3 NoGo 效应。N2 NoGo 效应在相似和不同的字母、相似的音调和不同的音调和新声音上都很显著。正如感知重叠假说所预期的那样,相似字母的 N2 NoGo 效应最大。相比之下,对于所有刺激集,P3 NoGo 效应都很显著,且幅度相似。刺激集的不同效果表明,N2 和 P3 反映了可分离的潜在过程。为希望在 Go/NoGo 任务中使用听觉刺激的临床研究人员提供了指导方针。