Interdisciplinary Palliative Care Unit, University Medical Center of the Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz, Mainz, Germany.
J Palliat Med. 2011 Aug;14(8):940-4. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2011.0025. Epub 2011 Jul 18.
The encounter of students and patients with a terminal illness plays an important role in this teaching. However, for ethical as well as practical reasons, there are limitations regarding the involvement of patients in palliative care teaching. In this study we investigate the effects of an obligatory 90-minute teaching intervention on a palliative care ward by means of quantitative and qualitative methods.
Self-perceived knowledge, confidence and attitudes were elicited by means of a questionnaire which has been developed by the authors. The instrument includes statements which could be answered by means of numerical rating scales - NRS (1 = very low, 10 = very high). In addition, open-ended questions regarding students' self-perceptions and evaluation of the teaching were analyzed according to the principles of content analysis.
All 163 participants completed the questionnaire. Participants rated their knowledge in palliative care as poor prior to the course (median, 3). Medical students indicated significantly improved confidence regarding the encounter with patients in palliative care (p < 0.001; median, 3 before versus 5.5 after), and higher interest for the subject of palliative care (median 7 before vs. 8 after). The student-patient encounter could be identified as a relevant factor contributing to the positive evaluation as part of the analysis of qualitative data.
This evaluation study of an obligatory course in palliative care indicates that even a short teaching module that includes a student-patient encounter has significant effects on the medical students' self-perceived knowledge, confidence and attitudes, and their interest in palliative care.
学生和终末期患者的相遇在这种教学中起着重要作用。然而,出于伦理和实际原因,患者在姑息治疗教学中的参与受到限制。在这项研究中,我们通过定量和定性方法研究了在姑息治疗病房进行强制性 90 分钟教学干预的效果。
通过作者开发的问卷,引出自我感知的知识、信心和态度。该工具包括可以通过数字评分量表(NRS)回答的陈述- NRS(1=非常低,10=非常高)。此外,根据内容分析的原则,对学生自我认知和教学评估的开放式问题进行了分析。
所有 163 名参与者都完成了问卷。参与者在课程前对姑息治疗的知识评价较差(中位数 3)。医学生表示在姑息治疗中与患者相遇的信心显著提高(p<0.001;中位数,3 前与 5.5 后),对姑息治疗科目的兴趣更高(中位数 7 前与 8 后)。学生与患者的相遇可以作为一个相关因素,作为定性数据分析的一部分,有助于对教学的积极评价。
这项姑息治疗必修课程的评估研究表明,即使是一个包含学生与患者相遇的短暂教学模块,也会对医学生的自我感知知识、信心和态度产生重大影响,并提高他们对姑息治疗的兴趣。