Department of Molecular Carcinogenesis, University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Science Park, PO Box 389, Smithville, TX 78957, USA.
Cancer Prev Res (Phila). 2011 Nov;4(11):1728-35. doi: 10.1158/1940-6207.CAPR-11-0166. Epub 2011 Jul 21.
Coxibs, including celecoxib, and other nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID), including aspirin, are among the most promising cancer chemopreventive agents in development today. This article examines the data on the efficacy of these agents in animal model studies of cancer prevention carried out by the authors. The studies evaluated here are restricted to our rodent models of colon/intestinal, bladder, and nonmelanoma skin cancer, in which celecoxib and other NSAIDs were administered as either cancer preventive or therapeutic agents. These studies may shed light on several questions. Is celecoxib unique compared with other NSAIDs, and if so, what implications would this have for human use? Are standard NSAIDs (which inhibit both COX-1 and COX-2) as effective as celecoxib in animal studies? Is the efficacy of celecoxib in particular or NSAIDs in general due to their off-target effects or to their effects on COX-1 and COX-2? What is the likely efficacy of low-dose aspirin? Some questions raised by human trials and epidemiology are discussed and related to our observations in animal model studies. We also discuss the problem of cardiovascular (CV) events associated with coxibs and certain other NSAIDs and whether results in animal models are predictive of efficacy in humans. On the basis of epidemiologic studies and its CV profile, aspirin seems to be the most promising NSAID for preventing human colorectal, bladder, and skin cancer, although the animal data for aspirin are less clear. A comprehensive understanding of the results of coxibs and other NSAIDs in animal studies may help inform and shape human trials of these commonly employed, relatively inexpensive, and highly effective compounds.
昔布类药物(包括塞来昔布)和其他非甾体抗炎药(NSAIDs),包括阿司匹林,是当今最有前途的癌症化学预防药物之一。本文检查了作者在癌症预防的动物模型研究中这些药物的疗效数据。这里评估的研究仅限于我们的结直肠/肠道、膀胱和非黑色素瘤皮肤癌的啮齿动物模型,在这些模型中,塞来昔布和其他 NSAIDs 被用作癌症预防或治疗剂。这些研究可能有助于回答以下几个问题。与其他 NSAIDs 相比,塞来昔布是否具有独特性,如果是这样,这对人类使用有何影响?标准 NSAIDs(同时抑制 COX-1 和 COX-2)在动物研究中与塞来昔布一样有效吗?塞来昔布或 NSAIDs 的疗效是否归因于它们的脱靶效应或对 COX-1 和 COX-2 的影响?低剂量阿司匹林的可能疗效如何?本文还讨论了一些人类临床试验和流行病学提出的问题,并与我们在动物模型研究中的观察结果相关。我们还讨论了与昔布类药物和某些其他 NSAIDs 相关的心血管(CV)事件问题,以及动物模型中的结果是否可预测人类的疗效。基于流行病学研究及其 CV 特征,阿司匹林似乎是预防人类结直肠、膀胱和皮肤癌最有前途的 NSAID,尽管阿司匹林的动物数据不太明确。全面了解昔布类药物和其他 NSAIDs 在动物研究中的结果,可能有助于为这些常用、相对廉价且非常有效的化合物的人类试验提供信息和指导。