Glycemic control: how tight in the intensive care unit?

Determining the optimal level of glycemic control in critical illness has proven difficult since the original Leuven study conclusions were published in 2001. Conflicting evidence, scientific methodologies, hospital cultures, and a-priori biases have challenged many clinical practice patterns. Specifically, the prioritization of patient safety has resulted in many practitioners changing from a glycemic control target of 80-110 mg/dL to a more liberal target of 140-180 mg/dL. However, a detailed examination of the evidence can provide a more population-specific glycemic control strategy. This position paper presents an approach for cardiac surgery patients in the intensive care unit (ICU) consistent with extant evidence and real-life variables. We argue that in the cardiac surgery ICU, glycemic targets may be as low as 80-110 mg/dL when formal intensive insulin therapy and nutrition support protocols are used with low rates of hypoglycemia, patient safety mechanisms, properly trained staff, and a supportive hospital administration all in force. Cardiac surgery ICUs that already follow this model may continue with 80-110 mg/dL blood glucose targets, whereas others may advance their blood glucose targets in a stepwise fashion: from 140 to 180 mg/dL to 110-140 mg/dL to 80-110 mg/dL, on the basis of their performance.