Neitzel Amber R, Gill James R
University of Arizona College of Medicine-Phoenix, 550 E Van Buren Street, Phoenix, AZ 85004, USA.
J Forensic Sci. 2011 Nov;56(6):1657-60. doi: 10.1111/j.1556-4029.2011.01891.x. Epub 2011 Aug 9.
Death certification of "suicide by cop" is controversial among some medical examiners and coroners. We present five such deaths that were certified as suicides and discuss the medico-legal issues involved with these certifications. To certify such a death as a suicide, certain criteria should be met. Suicide by cop is a circumstance that involves competing intentional acts that may result in dichotomous determinations of the manner of death. Despite the absence of direct self-infliction, there is overwhelming evidence that these five individuals intended to end their own lives. Their use of an unusual method to accomplish this goal may inappropriately result in a reflexive certification of homicide. All of the decedents possessed weapons or a facsimile of a weapon. We present five instances of suicide by cop and contend that these types of deaths are best certified as suicides.
“警察协助下自杀”的死亡证明在一些法医和验尸官中存在争议。我们呈现了五起被认定为自杀的此类死亡事件,并讨论了这些证明所涉及的法医学问题。要将此类死亡证明为自杀,应满足某些标准。警察协助下自杀是一种涉及相互冲突的故意行为的情况,这可能导致对死亡方式的二分法判定。尽管没有直接的自我伤害行为,但有压倒性的证据表明这五个人意图结束自己的生命。他们使用不寻常的方法来实现这一目标,可能会不恰当地导致对杀人罪的反射性认定。所有死者都持有武器或武器的仿制品。我们呈现了五起警察协助下自杀的案例,并认为这类死亡最好被证明为自杀。