Department of Surgery, Ajou University School of Medicine, Suwon, Korea.
J Breast Cancer. 2011 Mar;14(1):33-8. doi: 10.4048/jbc.2011.14.1.33. Epub 2011 Mar 31.
A 70-gene prognostic signature has prognostic value in patients with node-negative breast cancer in Europe. This diagnostic test known as "MammaPrint™ (70-gene prognostic signature)" was recently validated and implementation was feasible. Therefore, we assessed the 70-gene prognostic signature in Korean patients with breast cancer. We compared the risk predicted by the 70-gene prognostic signature with commonly used clinicopathological guidelines among Korean patients with breast cancer. We also analyzed the 70-gene prognostic signature and clinicopathological feature of the patients in comparison with a previous validation study.
Forty-eight eligible patients with breast cancer (clinical T1-2N0M0) were selected from four hospitals in Korea. Fresh tumor samples were analyzed with a customized microarray for the 70-gene prognostic signature. Concordance between the risk predicted by the 70-gene prognostic signature and risk predicted by commonly used clinicopathological guidelines (St. Gallen guidelines, National Institutes of Health [NIH] guideline, and Adjuvant! Online) was evaluated.
Prognosis signatures were assessed in 36 patients. No significant differences were observed in the clinicopathological features of patients compared with previous studies. The 70-gene prognosis signature identified five (13.9%) patients with a low-risk prognosis signature and 31 (86.1%) patients with a high-risk prognosis signature. Clinical risk was concordant with the prognosis signature for 29 patients (80.6%) according to the St. Gallen guidelines; 30 patients (83.4%) according to the NIH guidelines; and 23 patients (63.8%) according to the Adjuvant! Online. Our results were different from previous validation studies in Europe with about a 40% low-risk prognosis and about a 60% high-risk prognosis. The high incidence in the high-risk group was consistent with data in Japan.
The results of 70-gene prognostic signature of Korean patients with breast cancer were somewhat different from those identified in Europe. This difference should be studied as whether there is a gene disparity between Asians and Europeans. Further large-scale studies with a follow-up evaluation are required to assess whether the use of the 70-gene prognostic signature can predict the prognosis of Korean patients with breast cancer.
在欧洲,一种 70 基因预后标志对无淋巴结转移的乳腺癌患者具有预后价值。这种被称为“MammaPrint™(70 基因预后标志)”的诊断测试最近已经得到验证,并且可以实施。因此,我们评估了韩国乳腺癌患者的 70 基因预后标志。我们比较了 70 基因预后标志与韩国乳腺癌患者常用的临床病理指南预测的风险。我们还分析了 70 基因预后标志与临床病理特征,并与之前的验证研究进行了比较。
从韩国的四家医院中选择了 48 名符合条件的乳腺癌患者(临床 T1-2N0M0)。使用定制的微阵列分析新鲜肿瘤样本的 70 基因预后标志。评估了 70 基因预后标志预测的风险与常用临床病理指南(圣加仑指南、美国国立卫生研究院[ NIH ]指南和 Adjuvant! Online)预测的风险之间的一致性。
评估了 36 名患者的预后标志。与之前的研究相比,患者的临床病理特征没有显著差异。70 基因预后标志识别出 5 名(13.9%)低风险预后标志患者和 31 名(86.1%)高风险预后标志患者。根据圣加仑指南,临床风险与预后标志一致的患者有 29 名(80.6%);根据 NIH 指南,有 30 名(83.4%);根据 Adjuvant! Online,有 23 名(63.8%)。我们的结果与欧洲的验证研究不同,大约 40%的患者为低风险预后,大约 60%的患者为高风险预后。高危组的高发病率与日本的数据一致。
韩国乳腺癌患者 70 基因预后标志的结果与欧洲的结果有些不同。这种差异应该研究亚洲人和欧洲人之间是否存在基因差异。需要进一步进行大规模的研究并进行随访评估,以确定 70 基因预后标志是否可以预测韩国乳腺癌患者的预后。