Maurer M H, Winkler A, Wichlas F, Powerski M-J, Elgeti F, Huppertz A, Röttgen R, Marnitz T
Klinik für diagnostische und interventionelle Radiologie, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin.
Rofo. 2012 Jan;184(1):53-8. doi: 10.1055/s-0031-1281638. Epub 2011 Aug 23.
To assess the costs and diagnostic gain of abdominal ultrasound follow-up of polytrauma patients initially examined by whole-body computed tomography (CT).
A total of 176 patients with suspected multiple trauma (126 men, 50 women; age 43.5 ± 17.4 years) were retrospectively analyzed with regard to supplementary and new findings obtained by ultrasound follow-up compared with the results of exploratory FAST (focused assessment with sonography for trauma) at admission and the findings of whole-body CT. A process model was used to document the staff, materials, and total costs of the ultrasound follow-up examinations.
FAST yielded 26 abdominal findings (organ injury and/or free intra-abdominal fluid) in 19 patients, while the abdominal scan of whole-body CT revealed 32 findings in 25 patients. FAST had 81 % sensitivity and 100 % specificity. Follow-up ultrasound examinations revealed new findings in 2 of the 25 patients with abdominal injuries detected with initial CT. In the 151 patients without abdominal injuries in the initial CT scan, ultrasound follow-up did not yield any supplementary or new findings. The total costs of an ultrasound follow-up examination were EUR 28.93. The total costs of all follow-up ultrasound examinations performed in the study population were EUR 5658.23.
Follow-up abdominal ultrasound yields only a low overall diagnostic gain in polytrauma patients in whom initial CT fails to detect any abdominal injuries but incurs high personnel expenses for radiological departments.
评估对最初接受全身计算机断层扫描(CT)检查的多发伤患者进行腹部超声随访的成本和诊断收益。
回顾性分析了176例疑似多发伤患者(126例男性,50例女性;年龄43.5±17.4岁),比较了超声随访获得的补充和新发现与入院时创伤重点超声评估(FAST)结果及全身CT检查结果。采用过程模型记录超声随访检查的人员、材料和总成本。
FAST在19例患者中发现26项腹部异常(器官损伤和/或腹腔内游离液体),而全身CT腹部扫描在25例患者中发现32项异常。FAST的敏感性为81%,特异性为100%。随访超声检查在最初CT检查发现腹部损伤的25例患者中的2例发现了新的异常。在最初CT扫描未发现腹部损伤的151例患者中,超声随访未发现任何补充或新的异常。超声随访检查的总成本为28.93欧元。研究人群中所有随访超声检查的总成本为5658.23欧元。
对于最初CT未发现任何腹部损伤的多发伤患者,腹部超声随访的总体诊断收益较低,但会给放射科带来较高的人员费用。