Department of Biology, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USA.
J Theor Biol. 2011 Nov 7;288:35-43. doi: 10.1016/j.jtbi.2011.08.008. Epub 2011 Aug 17.
As overall size varies, the sizes of body parts of many animals often appear to be related to each other by a power law, commonly called the allometric equation. Orderly scaling relationships among body parts are widespread in the animal world, but there is no general agreement about how these relationships come about. Presumably they depend on the patterns of growth of body parts, and simple analyses have shown that exponential growth can lead to size relationships that are well-described by the allometric equation. Exponential growth kinetics also allow for a simple biological interpretation of the coefficients of the power relationship. Nevertheless, many tissues do not grow with exponential kinetics, nor do they grow for the same period of time, and the consequences of more realistic growth patterns on the resulting allometric relationships of body parts are not well understood. In this paper I derive a set of allometric equations that assume different kinetics of growth: linear, exponential and sigmoidal. In these derivations I also include differences in development times as a variable, in addition to differences in the growth rates and initial sizes of the two structures whose allometric relationship is compared. I show how these equations can be used to deduce the effect of different causes of variation in absolute size on the resulting allometry. Variation in size can be due to variation in the duration of development, variation in growth rate or variation in initial size. I show that the meaning of the coefficients of the allometric equation depends on exactly how size variation comes about. I show that if two structures are assumed to grow with sigmoidal kinetics (logistic and Gompertz) the resulting allometric equations do not have a simple and intuitive structure and produce graphs that, over a sufficiently large range of sizes, can vary from linear, to sigmoidal to hump-shaped. Over a smaller range of absolute sizes, these sigmoid growth kinetics can produce nearly linear allometries in both the arithmetic and logarithmic domains. I will argue that although growth kinetics are likely to be sigmoidal in most cases, natural selection will restrict variation in absolute size and the parameters of growth kinetics to regions where the allometric relations are linear, or nearly so.
由于总体大小不同,许多动物的身体部位大小通常似乎彼此之间存在幂律关系,通常称为异速方程。身体部位之间有序的比例关系在动物世界中广泛存在,但对于这些关系是如何产生的,尚无普遍共识。据推测,它们取决于身体部位的生长模式,并且简单的分析表明,指数增长可以导致身体部位的大小关系很好地由异速方程描述。指数增长动力学还为幂律关系的生物学解释提供了简单的方法。尽管如此,许多组织并非以指数增长动力学生长,也不是在同一时间段内生长,而且更现实的生长模式对身体部位产生的异速关系的影响还没有得到很好的理解。在本文中,我推导出了一组假设不同生长动力学的异速方程:线性、指数和 S 形。在这些推导中,我还将发育时间的差异作为一个变量包括在内,除了比较其异速关系的两个结构的生长速率和初始大小的差异。我展示了如何使用这些方程来推断绝对大小变化的不同原因对产生的异速关系的影响。大小的变化可能是由于发育持续时间的变化、生长速率的变化或初始大小的变化。我表明,异速方程的系数的含义取决于大小变化的确切方式。我表明,如果两个结构假设以 S 形生长动力学(对数和 Gompertz)生长,那么产生的异速方程没有简单直观的结构,并且生成的图形在足够大的尺寸范围内,可以从线性变化到 S 形变化到驼峰形变化。在较小的绝对尺寸范围内,这些 S 形生长动力学可以在算术和对数域中产生几乎线性的异速关系。我将认为,尽管在大多数情况下生长动力学可能是 S 形的,但自然选择将限制绝对大小和生长动力学参数的变化,使其处于异速关系为线性或接近线性的区域。