Miyake Keith K, Maroko Andrew R, Grady Kristen L, Maantay Juliana A, Arno Peter S
Earth and Environmental Sciences Program, The Graduate Center, and Department of Environmental, Geographic, and Geological Sciences, Lehman College, The City University of New York, 365 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10016,
Cities Environ. 2010 Jan 1;3(1):1-17. doi: 10.15365/cate.3182010.
The purpose of this study is to test the hypothesis that access to parks in New York City is not equitable across racial and ethnic categories. It builds on previous research that has linked access to parks and open space with increased physical activity, which in turn may reduce the risk for adverse health outcomes related to obesity. Systematic patterns of uneven access to parks might help to explain disparities in these health outcomes across sociodemographic populations that are not fully explained by individual-level risk factors and health behaviors, and therefore access to parks becomes an environmental justice issue. This study is designed to shed light on the "unpatterned inequities" of park distributions identified in previous studies of New York City park access. It uses a combination of network analysis and a cadastral-based expert dasymetric system (CEDS) to estimate the racial/ethnic composition of populations within a reasonable walking distance of 400m from parks. The distance to the closest park, number of parks within walking distance, amount of accessible park space, and number of physical activity sites are then evaluated across racial/ethnic categories, and are compared to the citywide populations using odds ratios. The odds ratios revealed patterns that at first glance appear to contradict the notion of distributional inequities. However, discussion of the results points to the need for reassessing what is meant by "access" to more thoroughly consider the aspects of parks that are most likely to contribute to physical activity and positive health outcomes.
纽约市公园的可达性在不同种族和族裔群体中并不公平。该研究建立在先前研究的基础之上,先前研究已将公园和开放空间的可达性与增加身体活动联系起来,而这反过来可能会降低与肥胖相关的不良健康结果的风险。公园可达性不均衡的系统模式可能有助于解释这些健康结果在社会人口群体中的差异,而这些差异无法完全由个体层面的风险因素和健康行为来解释,因此公园可达性成为一个环境正义问题。本研究旨在阐明先前纽约市公园可达性研究中所确定的公园分布的“无模式不平等”。它结合了网络分析和基于地籍的专家密度估计系统(CEDS),以估计距离公园400米合理步行范围内人口的种族/族裔构成。然后,评估不同种族/族裔群体到最近公园的距离、步行距离内的公园数量、可利用的公园空间数量以及体育活动场所的数量,并使用优势比与全市人口进行比较。优势比揭示的模式乍一看似乎与分布不平等的概念相矛盾。然而,对结果的讨论指出,有必要重新评估“可达性”的含义以便更全面地考虑公园中最有可能促进身体活动和产生积极健康结果的方面。