Foley Geraldine, Timonen Virpi, Hardiman Orla
Department of Occupational Therapy, National Neuroscience Centre, Beaumont Hospital, Dublin 9, Ireland.
Amyotroph Lateral Scler. 2012 Jan;13(1):11-24. doi: 10.3109/17482968.2011.607500. Epub 2011 Aug 31.
Service providers and service users often have different perspectives on health and social care services. We have undertaken a systematic review of empirical data between 1988 and March 2011 relating to ALS service users' perspectives on health and social care services. Forty-seven texts were extracted and a narrative synthesis conducted. Few studies have explored ALS patients' experiences in relation to their satisfaction with services. Our review showed that ALS patients expect dignified care but they are often dissatisfied with health care services and have unmet expectations of their care. Most studies of decision-making and preferences for care have focused on end-of-life intervention. Various factors influence preferences for care from the service user perspective and people with ALS may adjust their use of services as they negotiate change. In conclusion, further research on the timeliness of services to meet changing needs of service users is required. The service user experience of allied health care services prior to end-of-life care also warrants investigation. Service providers need to support people with ALS as they negotiate feelings of acceptance and independence. Research to identify the key parameters of the ALS patient experience of services is required.
服务提供者和服务使用者对健康和社会护理服务往往有不同的看法。我们对1988年至2011年3月间有关肌萎缩侧索硬化症(ALS)服务使用者对健康和社会护理服务看法的实证数据进行了系统综述。提取了47篇文献并进行了叙述性综合分析。很少有研究探讨ALS患者对服务满意度的体验。我们的综述表明,ALS患者期望得到有尊严的护理,但他们往往对医疗服务不满意,对护理的期望也未得到满足。大多数关于护理决策和偏好的研究都集中在临终干预方面。从服务使用者的角度来看,各种因素会影响对护理的偏好,而ALS患者在应对变化时可能会调整其服务使用情况。总之,需要进一步研究服务的及时性,以满足服务使用者不断变化的需求。临终护理之前联合健康护理服务的服务使用者体验也值得研究。服务提供者需要在ALS患者应对接受和独立感时给予支持。需要开展研究以确定ALS患者服务体验的关键参数。