Kim Hye Ryun, Cheon Seong Ha, Rha Sun Young, Lee Soohyeon, Han Kwang-Hyub, Chon Chae Yoon, Lee Jong Doo, Sung Jin Sil, Chung Hyun Cheol
Department of Internal Medicine, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Asia Pac J Clin Oncol. 2011 Sep;7(3):258-69. doi: 10.1111/j.1743-7563.2011.01425.x.
Liver transplantation (LT) is a curative treatment for localized hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), but the recurrence rate after LT is about 10-20%, with a dismal prognosis. Little data exist as to the natural history, treatment outcome and optimal treatment of recurrent HCC after LT. We reviewed various treatment modalities given to patients with recurrent HCC after LT.
Among 132 patients who underwent LT for localized HCC, we retrospectively reviewed medical records of 39 of the 132 patients who developed recurrent HCC after LT. We analyzed the clinical outcome of various treatment modalities and treatment-related adverse events.
A total of 39 (29%) of the original 132 patients had recurrent HCC, most recurrences (82%) having occurred within 1 year after LT and involved extrahepatic lesions. Only seven patients had recurrent disease limited to the liver. The median overall survival from the initial treatment of all relapsed patients was 6.9 months. There were various initial treatment modalities, namely palliative systemic chemotherapy, trans-catheter arterial chemo-embolization/infusion (TACE/I), radiation therapy (RT), surgical resection and no treatment. The median overall survival was 9.5 months for first-line chemotherapy, including those who had prior local therapy, 6.3 months TACE/I and 6.9 months for RT.
Various clinical approaches have been used to treat patients with recurrent HCC after LT in a clinical setting. More effective strategies and clinical guidelines for recurrent HCC following LT must be established.
肝移植(LT)是局限性肝细胞癌(HCC)的一种治愈性治疗方法,但LT后的复发率约为10%-20%,预后不佳。关于LT后复发性HCC的自然病史、治疗结果及最佳治疗方法的数据很少。我们回顾了给予LT后复发性HCC患者的各种治疗方式。
在132例因局限性HCC接受LT的患者中,我们回顾性分析了其中39例LT后发生复发性HCC患者的病历。我们分析了各种治疗方式的临床结果及与治疗相关的不良事件。
132例初始患者中共有39例(29%)发生复发性HCC,大多数复发(82%)发生在LT后1年内,且累及肝外病变。只有7例患者的复发性疾病局限于肝脏。所有复发患者从初始治疗开始的中位总生存期为6.9个月。初始治疗方式有多种,即姑息性全身化疗、经导管动脉化疗栓塞/灌注(TACE/I)、放射治疗(RT)、手术切除及未治疗。一线化疗(包括那些曾接受过局部治疗的患者)的中位总生存期为9.5个月,TACE/I为6.3个月,RT为6.9个月。
在临床环境中,已采用多种临床方法治疗LT后复发性HCC患者。必须建立更有效的LT后复发性HCC治疗策略和临床指南。