School of Clinical Medicine University of Cambridge, UK.
Psychiatr Danub. 2011 Sep;23 Suppl 1:S126-9.
Behavioural and psychological symptoms in dementia (BPSD) are common and distressing. Anti psychotic medication has been shown to have modest efficacy but is associated with well documented risks including excess cardiovascular events and increased mortality. The current NICE recommendations are that antipsychotics should only be prescribed to those with severe BPSD after exploring other possible interventions. There should be adequate counselling of the patient/family, an explicit risk-benefit analysis and regular review.
As part of the POMH-UK National Audit on antipsychotic prescribing in dementia we reviewed the notes of 67 patients in the Cambridgeshire area who had a diagnosis of dementia.
Of the 67 patients reviewed, only 9 (13.4%) were currently being prescribed antipsychotics for BPSD. Of these patients, all were living in their own homes and were experiencing multiple distressing target symptoms. 5 had been prescribed an antipsychotic for less than 3 months and only 1 had a total duration of treatment of more than 1 year. There was good evidence in all cases that alternative diagnoses and management strategies had been explored before prescribing an antipsychotic. However, in none was the full range of potential causes or interventions explored. In 6 cases a risk/benefit analysis for use of antipsychotic medicine was recorded and in 5 cases there was documented discussion of this with family or carers. Of the four patients who had been prescribed an antipsychotic for more than 3 months, three had had two or more medication reviews. The fourth patient had had a trial of stopping the medication. Prescribing of other psychotropic medication was also reviewed. Benzodiazepines were used sparingly (7.5%). Of note a significant minority of patients (10.4%) were prescribed 3 or more different psychotropic medications.
These results suggest that within this service antipsychotics are being used appropriately to enable patients with distressing and difficult behaviour to continue to remain at home. They were generally prescribed for a short time and reviewed. Areas for improvement include a documented discussion of risk in all cases and ensuring that all possible causes of BPSD have been ruled out. Regular review of efficacy and tolerability is essential for all pharmacological treatments for BPSD particularly for those prescribed multiple psychotropic medications.
痴呆患者的行为和心理症状(BPSD)很常见且令人痛苦。抗精神病药物已被证明具有一定疗效,但也存在众所周知的风险,包括心血管事件增加和死亡率增加。目前 NICE 的建议是,只有在探索了其他可能的干预措施后,才应将抗精神病药物开给那些有严重 BPSD 的患者。应充分告知患者/家属,进行明确的风险效益分析,并定期进行审查。
作为 POMH-UK 全国抗精神病药物在痴呆症中的使用情况审计的一部分,我们对剑桥地区的 67 名诊断为痴呆症的患者的病历进行了审查。
在审查的 67 名患者中,仅有 9 名(13.4%)目前因 BPSD 而开抗精神病药物。在这些患者中,所有人都居住在自己家中,并且经历了多种令人痛苦的目标症状。其中 5 人服用抗精神病药物不到 3 个月,只有 1 人治疗时间超过 1 年。在所有情况下,都有充分的证据表明在开抗精神病药物之前已经探索了其他诊断和管理策略。但是,没有一个案例全面探讨了潜在的原因或干预措施。在 6 例中,记录了使用抗精神病药物的风险/收益分析,在 5 例中,与家人或护理人员讨论了此问题。在因 BPSD 而服用抗精神病药物超过 3 个月的 4 名患者中,有 3 名接受了两次或更多次药物审查。第四名患者接受了停药试验。同时还审查了其他精神药物的处方。苯二氮䓬类药物的使用量很少(7.5%)。值得注意的是,少数患者(10.4%)开了 3 种或更多种不同的精神药物。
这些结果表明,在本服务中,抗精神病药物的使用是合理的,使有痛苦和困难行为的患者能够继续在家中生活。它们通常短期开处方并进行审查。需要改进的地方包括在所有情况下记录风险讨论,并确保排除 BPSD 的所有可能原因。对于 BPSD 的所有药物治疗,包括开多种精神药物的患者,定期评估疗效和耐受性至关重要。