Makris Susan L, Kim James H, Ellis Amy, Faber Willem, Harrouk Wafa, Lewis Joseph M, Paule Merle G, Seed Jennifer, Tassinari Melissa, Tyl Rochelle
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Center for Environmental Assessment, Office of Research and Development, Washington, District of Columbia.
Birth Defects Res B Dev Reprod Toxicol. 2011 Oct;92(5):384-94. doi: 10.1002/bdrb.20335. Epub 2011 Sep 15.
A review is presented of the use of developmental toxicity testing in the United States and international regulatory assessment of human health risks associated with exposures to pharmaceuticals (human and veterinary), chemicals (agricultural, industrial, and environmental), food additives, cosmetics, and consumer products. Developmental toxicology data are used for prioritization and screening of pharmaceuticals and chemicals, for evaluating and labeling of pharmaceuticals, and for characterizing hazards and risk of exposures to industrial and environmental chemicals. The in vivo study designs utilized in hazard characterization and dose-response assessment for developmental outcomes have not changed substantially over the past 30 years and have served the process well. Now there are opportunities to incorporate new technologies and approaches to testing into the existing assessment paradigm, or to apply innovative approaches to various aspects of risk assessment. Developmental toxicology testing can be enhanced by the refinement or replacement of traditional in vivo protocols, including through the use of in vitro assays, studies conducted in alternative nonmammalian species, the application of new technologies, and the use of in silico models. Potential benefits to the current regulatory process include the ability to screen large numbers of chemicals quickly, with the commitment of fewer resources than traditional toxicology studies, and to refine the risk assessment process through an enhanced understanding of the mechanisms of developmental toxicity and their relevance to potential human risk. As the testing paradigm evolves, the ability to use developmental toxicology data to meet diverse critical regulatory needs must be retained.
本文综述了发育毒性试验在美国以及国际上用于评估与接触药品(人用和兽用)、化学品(农业、工业和环境用)、食品添加剂、化妆品及消费品相关的人类健康风险的情况。发育毒理学数据用于药品和化学品的优先排序与筛选、药品的评估与标签标注,以及确定工业和环境化学品暴露的危害与风险。过去30年里,用于发育结局危害特征描述和剂量反应评估的体内研究设计基本未变,且运行良好。现在有机会将新技术和测试方法纳入现有的评估范式,或在风险评估的各个方面应用创新方法。发育毒理学试验可通过改进或替代传统的体内试验方案来加强,包括使用体外试验、在非哺乳动物替代物种中进行的研究、新技术的应用以及计算机模拟模型的使用。对当前监管流程的潜在益处包括能够快速筛选大量化学品,与传统毒理学研究相比所需资源更少,以及通过增强对发育毒性机制及其与潜在人类风险相关性的理解来完善风险评估流程。随着测试范式的演变,必须保留利用发育毒理学数据满足各种关键监管需求的能力。